ThomasRahm
commented
11 months ago It seems to me that this bug is not in the tree support code. I am not getting an overhang for the small part, and the tree support only supports areas that were detected as overhangs If the support overhang angle is reduced (e.g. to 55°) it will be detected as overhang.
It seems to me that the issue could be in computeBasicAndFullOverhang in support.cpp and may be related to smooth_height as when i set it to 0.2, the overhang will be detected.
Edit: In the loop for this smoothing it is never checked whether the areas of the layers below overlap, causing pointy overhangs to be wrongly detected as features of nearby walls.
MariMakes
Cura Version
5.4.0
Operating System
win 10
Printer
ender3
Reproduction steps
load project file and slice.
https://i.imgur.com/KIsOEvP.png https://i.redd.it/6c2e7iqnsicb1.png
On the left i got Cura 5.3 and on the right is 5.4
in the blue circle you can see the pointy lower end of the shield (printing a miniature) being supported. but on the 5.4 version its not getting a support.
file: https://www.thingiverse.com/thing:5921500
printing on a angle for better layer adhesion and so tree support can get everywhere without ever needing to start on the base of the mini. project file: https://www.mediafire.com/file/h5i9tlfqo70xc29/warforged_with_missing_supports.3mf/file
Actual results
some parts of the model dont get supported.
Expected results
supported flying areas
Add your .zip and screenshots here ⬇️
https://www.mediafire.com/file/h5i9tlfqo70xc29/warforged_with_missing_supports.3mf/file @ThomasRahm