Ultimaker / Cura

3D printer / slicing GUI built on top of the Uranium framework
GNU Lesser General Public License v3.0
6.12k stars 2.07k forks source link

5.8.0 Infill after change pattern doesn't work Using the standard Fast - Engeneering -0.2mm profile #19640

Closed marcovalstar closed 1 month ago

marcovalstar commented 1 month ago

Cura Version

5.8.0

Operating System

Windows 11

Printer

Ulitmaker S5

Reproduction steps

I make a new project and choose my printing profile Than i load my models (2 models that are merged because of printing 2 different colors) Then i sliced the model. Not satisfied from the result i change the infill dencity and/or the pattern but that doesn't have any effect after re-slicing

Actual results

Using the standard Fast - Engeneering -0.2mm profile The re-slicing is the same as the result before the changes

Expected results

I expect the infill changed from for example 25% to 75% and the standard pattern (grid) changes to the choosen (Gyroid)

Add your .zip and screenshots here ⬇️

Change_infill.zip

GregValiant commented 1 month ago

Thanks for the report. We ask for project files so we get your Cura settings, your printer, and the model. Without it I would be guessing and I respectfully refuse to do that.

marcovalstar commented 1 month ago

Error_slicing_VRT.zip

Sorry for not given all the information. Here it is.

GregValiant commented 1 month ago

There is so little infill in the letters, and the infill is just a single layer. It's hard to tell what is going on. This is my slice of the project with no changes (E2 is Gyroid at 25% and E1 is Triangles at 20%) image When I change E2 to 75%: image

When I scale the model up it slices like this which appears is correct. This is with E2 left at your 25% infill density. image

I don't see a bug here and I can't duplicate the problem. Your project does not contain the settings you describe above and the CuraProfile you provided does not contain the settings you describe above. When I change the infill density, the infill density changes. The infill areas of the letters are so small and shallow that they would not require any infill at all.

I'm going to remove the bug from this. I'm inclined to close it as well. Let me know if you feel that is premature.

marcovalstar commented 1 month ago

I know what you said for this part it is not realy nescesairry but you want an example. The problem is (i think) that the program doesn't response consequently like you can see in the movie i made. Ther you can see i load a part and slice it then i delete the part and load another. When i then change the settings the slicing is not what i espected. It doesn't change the slicing after adjusting the parameters. For this part it it isn't a problem but i also have seen this with other objects (larger). If you start Cura change the settings than load the model everything works fine. But after deleting the model and loading another this problem occurs (i think).

Error Slicing Vrt Movie HB.zip

But no big deal just want to let you now and maybe you find the isseu and fix it, when not i just start a new project every time i load a new model. Anyway, thanks for looking at my problem greatings Marco

GregValiant commented 1 month ago

I can't duplicate this. I change the extruder settings and they are reflected in the slice. I'm using your project, I just scaled it up a bit so the infill areas are larger. I have changed the infill pattern and density a bunch of different ways and it always appears in the print per my settings. I'll put the bug label back on this for you and someone from the Cura team ( @HellAholic ??) will take a look.

This happens to be with "Lines" and a custom sine wave infill I designed. Everything worked as expected. image

Here I've switched patterns and density and tile size from one part to the other. image

HellAholic commented 1 month ago

Hey @marcovalstar, Based on the video, you're changing the infill setting for extruder 1 and you're inspecting the model/part assigned to extruder 2. Your base (in yellow color) is set to extruder 2. image and the text (in grey color) is set to extruder 1. On the print setting panel you can see that the changes you're making are under extruder 1 tab. image So when you're changing the infill density and pattern of the text part (in grey color / extruder 1), and therefore you will not see the change in the base (which is assigned to extruder 2).

Some settings can be changed per extruder, some per model/mesh, and some globally. For infill specifically, if you're in the recommended view, you can set the infill globally for both extruders. image

Could you check and see if that is the source of the issue you're experiencing?

marcovalstar commented 1 month ago

You are so right i feel kind of stupid now :-(. That was indeed the problem. I should check the extruder first before changing the settings. Excuses for the time you spend on me. Good thing is i learnd something thanks.

GregValiant commented 1 month ago

I'll go ahead and close this then.