search

Ultimaker / Cura

3D printer / slicing GUI built on top of the Uranium framework
GNU Lesser General Public License v3.0
6.08k stars 2.06k forks source link

[3.4.1] Adaptive layering interferes with support structure generation #4396

Open kulfuerst opened 6 years ago

kulfuerst commented 6 years ago

Application Version 3.4.1

Platform Windows 10

Printer Anycubic i3 Mega

Steps to Reproduce Enable adaptive layers, enable support generation, set support overhang angle to 60% or lower

Actual Results size of generated support structure is greatly reduced when adaptive layering is enabled, in spite of a set support overhang angle.

Expected results No change in generated support structures

Additional Information cura adaptive cura not adaptive

nallath commented 6 years ago

Unfortunately, I don't think there is much we can do to fix this. The reason this happens is because of the way we actually slice; We try to go to 2D layers as fast as possible. Since we compare the area we need to support based on subtracting layers from each other, we might incorrectly select certain areas if the resolution is different.

kulfuerst commented 6 years ago

May there possibly be a work around then if the issue itself cannot be fixed? Some method to maybe trick Cura into generating more support?

diegopradogesto commented 5 years ago

In this specific case, you can try reducing the overhang angle. Other option you can use is to create a custom support (for instance using the Custom Supports package in the Toolbox) in that part with the exact size you desire.

Ghostkeeper commented 5 years ago

I think this can be solved (with some work). We compute the overhang distance by taking the tangent of the overhang angle and multiplying that with the layer height. We currently always use the layer height setting, but there it should use the actual height of the layer.

This sort of problem is everywhere in the engine. The adaptive layer height implementation is vastly incomplete in that regard, which is why it's in Experimental.