marwin89
commented
10 months ago SUMMARY / FINAL RESULT 🚩
Thanks for voting. Here are the final results for this issue.
We introduce #TAGS and use #EDITION only for music games.
❤ 5 🚀 0 🎉 0 👀 : 1
Details
- #EDITION is only for "Editions of games" like SingStar - Pop Hits, GuitarHero Live, Rockband vol.4, Let's Sing 2020
- add a new attribute #TAGS (with multiple entries) that can contain "any reasonable keyword" for this song to be found like topic, mood, place etc.: for example: Love Songs , Movie , 80s
- write the "version of a song" into #TITLE with ( )
- Song Editors have a auto complete function in GUI that adds these common keywords into #TAGS: Party, Feel-Good, Charts, Cover Songs, Summer, Pride / LGBTQ, Love Songs, Heartbreak / Sadness, Guilty Pleasure, Disney, Underrated, Christmas, Halloween, Eurovision Song Contest [YEAR], Club / Dancefloor, Viral Hit, Relaxed, Special Interest, Funny, Underground, Mainstream, Slow
Why?
- users in usdb don't know how to use #EDITION, its inconsistent
- we need a clear definition, #GENRE seems to be not enough for different keywords
Examples:
#TITLE: Final Countdown (live)
#EDITION: Rockband vol.4
#TAGS: Love Songs , Movie , 80sText on Website
TAGS allows you to add any reasonable keyword for this song to be found like topic, mood etc. You can add multiple tags and seperate them with comma.
#TAGS: Summer, Cover Songs, Charts
Suggestion
SUMMARY / VOTE NOW 📈 ✋
Present situation: users use #EDITION for different things (Album, decade, topic etc.) in usdb, its inconsistent. There was no official definition for that attribute in format.
We need to define #EDITION. There was a long discussion in discord that I summarize here.
Here are the voting options.
Please vote for this issue till 31th oct 2023 with emoticon 🎉 / 🚀 / ❤️ .
🚀 A: deprecate #EDITION at all
🎉 B: define #EDITION only for "Editions of games" like SingStar - Pop Hits, GuitarHero Live, Rockband vol.4, Let's Sing 2020
❤️ C: define #EDITION only for "Editions of games" like SingStar - Pop Hits, GuitarHero Live, Rockband vol.4, Let's Sing 2020
AND add a new attribute #TAGS (with multiple entries) that can contain "any reasonable keyword" for this song to be found like topic, mood, etc.: for example: Love Songs , Movie , 80s AND write the "version of a song" into #TITLE with ( )
👀 D: define #EDITION only for the "version of a song": "live version", "Explicit", "Video Version", "Remix", "12inch version", "Album version"
AND add a new attribute #TAGS (with multiple entries) that can contain "any reasonable keyword" for this song to be found like topic, mood, etc.: for example: Eurovision Song Contest , Glam Rock , Pride
Use case
Why?
Extra info/examples/attachments
Examples:
A:
B:
C:
D:
Spreadsheet for defining common #TAGS/#KEYWORDS for USDB/Tools