search

UniversalConceptualCognitiveAnnotation / docs

UCCA Documentation
https://universalconceptualcognitiveannotation.github.io/
10 stars 1 forks source link

Section on restrictions? #31

Open nschneid opened 6 years ago

nschneid commented 6 years ago

There were some restrictions that I learned about today from Omri:

Maybe these are mentioned somewhere in the guidelines, but I think it would be nice to have a compact description of which categories can occur under which other categories, which categories can be combined on the same unit (like S+A), and so forth.

dotdv commented 6 years ago

Yes, definitely, I will try to phrase something.

dotdv commented 6 years ago

For now, until we add something to the guidelines here are some basic restrictions: P/S, D, T, A and G can appear only in Scene units. C, E and N can only appear in non-Scene units Q, R and F can appear both in Scene as well in non-Scene units. Regarding types of scene units: currently the guidelines allow only for H scenes, A scenes and E scenes.

nschneid commented 6 years ago

Great! The thing you mentioned about coordination ("D in coordination", https://github.com/UniversalConceptualCognitiveAnnotation/docs/issues/28#issuecomment-421747396) is an exception, right?

dotdv commented 6 years ago

Right.

nschneid commented 6 years ago

Is it true that only A, D, and T can be remote? https://github.com/UniversalConceptualCognitiveAnnotation/docs/issues/34#issuecomment-424972891

What about:

dotdv commented 6 years ago

Is it true that only A, D, and T can be remote? #34 (comment)

I didn't mean to say that, sorry if I misled you.

I wrote you a long reply but deleted it since I just remembered that we changed the Remote section, and I myself am now confused how we should treat Remote in coordination.

I can just say that your suggestion of repeating all the elided material as remote will probably solve the ambiguity as to what unit is necessary and what unit isn't. But it's an essentially different approach from the principle we followed so far, so I'll leave it up to Omri to determine.

dotdv commented 5 years ago

I added a restrictions summary chapter draft to the end of the guidelines. At first I thought it could open chapter 2: "a birds eye's view of the categories" but I wasn't sure about it, so eventually added it to the end by default.

nschneid commented 5 years ago

I agree, this is sufficiently technical that it's better to have at the end of the doc.

nschneid commented 5 years ago

It says that only H and L can occur at the top-level. What about G, as in: "Unfortunately, to graduate in time, I need to take this course"?

omriabnd commented 5 years ago

Sounds good

On Mon, Oct 22, 2018 at 2:33 PM dotdv notifications@github.com wrote:

I added a restrictions summary chapter draft to the end of the guidelines. At first I thought it could open chapter 2: "a birds eye's view of the categories" but I wasn't sure about it, so eventually added it to the end by default.

— You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/UniversalConceptualCognitiveAnnotation/docs/issues/31#issuecomment-431808659, or mute the thread https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AIG861AHDqe68n9ORuvZ-ngDaACFxqWIks5unazygaJpZM4WxT3M .

omriabnd commented 5 years ago

By convention we putwithin the scene although it's understood it takes scope over it.

On Mon, 22 Oct 2018, 17:34 Nathan Schneider, notifications@github.com wrote:

It says that only H and L can occur at the top-level. What about G, as in: "Unfortunately, to graduate in time, I need to take this course"?

— You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/UniversalConceptualCognitiveAnnotation/docs/issues/31#issuecomment-431853365, or mute the thread https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AIG860FSbsTDCa6wo4zBOwp7v7MbkbLWks5unddggaJpZM4WxT3M .