UniversalDependencies / UD_English-GUM

Other
32 stars 4 forks source link

Mentions crossing sentence boundaries #8

Closed martinpopel closed 3 years ago

martinpopel commented 3 years ago

Are mentions allowed to cross sentence boundaries? (I can imagine e.g. "Are You There God? It's Me, Margaret." may be such case, depending on sentence segmentation rules.) Is the following mention substance-14 (spanning "Ingredients Method 1") correctly annotated?

# sent_id = GUM_whow_cupcakes-8
# text = Ingredients
# s_type = frag
1       Ingredients     ingredient      NOUN    NNS     Number=Plur     0       root    _       Discourse=preparation:12->19|Entity=(substance-14

# sent_id = GUM_whow_cupcakes-9
# text = Method 1: Basic Vanilla Vegan Cupcakes:
# s_type = frag
1       Method  method  NOUN    NN      Number=Sing     0       root    _       Bridge=abstract-2<abstract-15|Discourse=preparation:13->14|Entity=(abstract-15
2       1       1       NUM     CD      NumForm=Digit|NumType=Card      1       dep     _       Entity=substance-14)abstract-15)|SpaceAfter=No
3       :       :       PUNCT   :       _       7       punct   _       _
4       Basic   basic   ADJ     JJ      Degree=Pos      7       amod    _       Discourse=preparation:14->19|Entity=(object-3
5       Vanilla vanilla NOUN    NN      Number=Sing     7       compound        _       _
6       Vegan   vegan   ADJ     JJ      Degree=Pos      7       amod    _       _
7       Cupcakes        cupcake NOUN    NNS     Number=Plur     1       appos   _       Entity=object-3)|SpaceAfter=No
8       :       :       PUNCT   :       _       1       punct   _       _
amir-zeldes commented 3 years ago

No, this is an annotation error, will fix and thanks for reporting! Even though it is conceivable that a mention could cross sentences (especially in discourse deixis), we do not allow it in GUM.