UniversalDependencies / UD_Faroese-OFT

Other
1 stars 2 forks source link

Relative clauses introduced with an adverb #6

Closed ftyers closed 6 years ago

ftyers commented 6 years ago

Of the type introduced by har "there":

# text = Í dag er fótbóltsvøllur, har Holið var.
# text[eng] = Today there is a football field, where The Hole was.
# labels = to_check
"<Í>"
        "í" Pr @case #1->2
"<dag>"
        "dagur" N Msc Sg Acc Indef @obl #2->4
"<er>"
        "vera" V Ind Prs Sg3 @cop #3->4
"<fótbóltsvøllur>"
        "fótbóltsvøllur" N Msc Sg Nom Indef @root #4->0
"<,>"
        "," CLB @punct #5->8
"<har>"
        "har" Adv @advmod #6->8
"<Holið>"
        "hol" N Neu Sg Nom Def @nsubj #7->8
"<var>"
        "vera" V Ind Prt Sg3 @acl #8->4
"<.>"
        "." CLB @punct #9->4

Bokmål

Bokmål has the adverb as a subordinating conjunction with mark.

# sent_id =  001044
# text = Men det kunne også bli i Bretagne, der hun har hus.
1       Men     men     CCONJ   _       _       5       cc      _       _
2       det     det     PRON    _       Gender=Neut|Number=Sing|Person=3|PronType=Prs   5       nsubj   _       _
3       kunne   kunne   AUX     _       Mood=Ind|Tense=Past|VerbForm=Fin        5       aux     _       _
4       også    også    ADV     _       _       5       advmod  _       _
5       bli     bli     VERB    _       VerbForm=Inf    0       root    _       _
6       i       i       ADP     _       _       7       mark    _       _
7       Bretagne        Bretagne        PROPN   _       _       5       xcomp   _       SpaceAfter=No
8       ,       $,      PUNCT   _       _       7       punct   _       _
9       der     der     SCONJ   _       _       11      mark    _       _
10      hun     hun     PRON    _       Animacy=Hum|Case=Nom|Gender=Fem|Number=Sing|Person=3|PronType=Prs       11      nsubj   _       _
11      har     ha      VERB    _       Mood=Ind|Tense=Pres|VerbForm=Fin        7       acl     _       _
12      hus     hus     NOUN    _       Definite=Ind|Gender=Neut|Number=Sing    11      obj     _       SpaceAfter=No
13      .       $.      PUNCT   _       _       5       punct   _       _

Nynorsk

Nynorsk as Bokmål:

# sent_id =  006965
# text = Firda har fått tilgang til SMS-en, der Fjæren skriv følgjande:
1       Firda   Firda   PROPN   _       _       3       nsubj   _       _
2       har     ha      AUX     _       Mood=Ind|Tense=Pres|VerbForm=Fin        3       aux     _       _
3       fått    få      VERB    _       VerbForm=Part   0       root    _       _
4       tilgang tilgang NOUN    _       Definite=Ind|Gender=Masc|Number=Sing    3       obj     _       _
5       til     til     ADP     _       _       6       case    _       _
6       SMS-en  SMS     NOUN    _       Definite=Def|Gender=Masc|Number=Sing    4       nmod    _       SpaceAfter=No
7       ,       $,      PUNCT   _       _       6       punct   _       _
8       der     der     SCONJ   _       _       10      mark    _       _
9       Fjæren  Fjæren  PROPN   _       _       10      nsubj   _       _
10      skriv   skrive  VERB    _       Mood=Ind|Tense=Pres|VerbForm=Fin        6       acl     _       _
11      følgjande       følgje  ADJ     _       VerbForm=Part   10      obj     _       SpaceAfter=No
12      :       $:      PUNCT   _       _       3       punct   _       _

Swedish

Swedish has the introducing adverb as advmod.

# sent_id = sv-ud-train-2186
# text = Vad har då hänt i ett par länder, där man avskaffat hyresregleringen?
1       Vad     vad     PRON    HP|NEU|SIN|IND  Definite=Ind|Gender=Neut|Number=Sing|PronType=Int       4       nsubj   _       _
2       har     ha      AUX     VB|PRS|AKT      Mood=Ind|Tense=Pres|VerbForm=Fin|Voice=Act      4       aux     _       _
3       då      då      ADV     AB      _       4       advmod  _       _
4       hänt    hända   VERB    VB|SUP|AKT      VerbForm=Sup|Voice=Act  0       root    _       _
5       i       i       ADP     PP      _       8       case    _       _
6       ett     en      DET     DT|NEU|SIN|IND  Definite=Ind|Gender=Neut|Number=Sing|PronType=Art       7       det     _       _
7       par     par     NOUN    NN|NEU|SIN|IND|NOM      Case=Nom|Definite=Ind|Gender=Neut|Number=Sing   8       nmod    _       _
8       länder  land    NOUN    NN|NEU|PLU|IND|NOM      Case=Nom|Definite=Ind|Gender=Neut|Number=Plur   4       obl     _       SpaceAfter=No
9       ,       ,       PUNCT   MID     _       8       punct   _       _
10      där     där     ADV     HA      _       12      advmod  _       _
11      man     man     PRON    PN|UTR|SIN|IND|SUB      Case=Nom|Definite=Ind|Gender=Com|Number=Sing|PronType=Ind       12      nsubj   _       _
12      avskaffat       avskaffa        VERB    VB|SUP|AKT      VerbForm=Sup|Voice=Act  8       acl:relcl       _       _
13      hyresregleringen        hyresreglering  NOUN    NN|UTR|SIN|DEF|NOM      Case=Nom|Definite=Def|Gender=Com|Number=Sing    12      obj     _       SpaceAfter=No
14      ?       ?       PUNCT   MAD     _       4       punct   _       _

Danish

The construction in Danish seems to work a bit differently, requiring hvor "where": Men det kunne også blive i Bretagne, hvor hun har et hus.

jnivre commented 6 years ago

Since we generally favor an argument or modifier relation, rather than "mark", for the element introducing a relative clause, I don't think "mark" should be used in these cases.

ftyers commented 6 years ago

@jnivre that sounds good to me, @liljao can this be changed in Norwegian ? (also, note that Swedish has acl:relcl here where Norwegian has plain acl).