search

UniversalDependencies / UD_Portuguese-PUD

Parallel Universal Dependencies.
Other
5 stars 3 forks source link

question: cabelo na China? #32

Closed vcvpaiva closed 3 years ago

vcvpaiva commented 3 years ago

sent_id = n01025040 text = Na China, o cabelo é normalmente colocado num banho químico para remover por completo a cutícula, explica Tarlo. text_en = In China the hair is typically put in a chemical bath to remove the cuticle completely, Tarlo explains.

The English root is "explains", the PT root is colocado/put. Parataxis is a difficult one, is the main clause "Tarlo explains" or what he explains=In China the hair is typically put in a chemical bath to remove the cuticle completel ?

dan-zeman commented 3 years ago

According to the guidelines (example 10 therein), the annotation in English PUD is wrong. The root should be put, while explains should be attached to it as parataxis.

(Personally I don't quite like this guideline. But that's how it stands :-))

vcvpaiva commented 3 years ago

many thanks, closing it.