VFansss / mgs2-v-s-fix

Unofficial fix for PC version of Metal Gear Solid 2
Other
567 stars 23 forks source link

Mono instead of stereo voices during opening cutscene of the Plant mission #140

Open Foxiravoc opened 3 years ago

Foxiravoc commented 3 years ago

I used to have an audio bug during the opening cutscene of the Plant mission where I can only hear the voices in my left ear. I thought this problem has always been present in the base game until I decided to do a fresh install and play it without the patches and the voices are now in stereo as they should be. That is until I apply the patches again, whether it is 1.7 or 1.8.

MGS2_VFix_debug.txt

VFansss commented 3 years ago

Can you please tell me what audio sample rate are you using?

Foxiravoc commented 3 years ago

I went through every possible audio sample rate already, checked and unchecked boxes but the problem still occurs. I should also add that the sound FX are not affected but only the voices and the issue persists until the first CODEC communication where the voices resume back to stereo from there on.

VFansss commented 3 years ago

Are these 2 options selected?

immagine

In alternative, you can try to use IndirectSound?

Just extract the 2 files from the zip inside the main game folder. Overwrite. Then launch mgs2_sse.exe

Foxiravoc commented 3 years ago

(Un)checking these boxes didn't make a difference before and after I applied IndirectSound.

VFansss commented 3 years ago

So I guess that even with IndirectSound, the issue is not fixed?

With the original GOG release you don't have this issue?

Foxiravoc commented 3 years ago

So I guess that even with IndirectSound, the issue is not fixed?

IndirectSound didn't fix the problem.

With the original GOG release you don't have this issue?

No issue until I apply the patch.

VFansss commented 3 years ago

I guess the only way to pinpoint what is fixing/breaking it is to apply only my audio fix to the original GOG version.

If you want, you could delete all (uninstall + manual delete of the game folder) reinstall the game using GOG release, run the game and check that everything is ok.

Then manually apply ON THE GOG RELEASE THIS audio fix.

Then do a simple test: is the audio broken or is working good?

Foxiravoc commented 3 years ago

If you want, you could delete all (uninstall + manual delete of the game folder) reinstall the game using GOG release, run the game and check that everything is ok.

The GOG release doesn't have that issue until I apply the patch.

Then manually apply ON THE GOG RELEASE THIS audio fix.

Applying the audio fix alone to the GOG version without patching it doesn't break the sound.

VFansss commented 3 years ago

Ok, is like I tought: there's some kind of incompatibility with other .dll I'm using.

Can you please send me your mgs2.ini you have now (without V's fix) and AFTER applying the V's fix?

VFansss commented 3 years ago

Ok, let's recap:

I know that is annoying, but is the only chance I have to solve this 😛

Foxiravoc commented 3 years ago

REMINDER: The issue occurs throughout the Plant opening sequence until the first CODEC communication where the voices resume back to stereo from there on.

GOG version ---- Voices: Stereo / Sound FX: Stereo => GOOD

Audio fix only --- Voices: Stereo / Sound FX: Stereo => GOOD

Patch applied --- Voices: Left channel / Sound FX: Stereo => BROKEN

I included 2 mgs2.ini files for before and after the game got patched.

mgs2_ini.zip