VacantFanatic / SLAfoundry

beta for SLA Industries for Foundry VTT
MIT License
3 stars 0 forks source link

Skill dice rolls #51

Closed Rafynwolf closed 7 months ago

Rafynwolf commented 8 months ago

When I roll a skill roll the results do not appear on the activity log. 3D dice for Dice so nice also do not roll. If I refresh the page the results appear. If I roll a attribute roll then the dice do roll and the results appear.
I am using Foundry hosted on forge using Norton Security Web Browser.

VacantFanatic commented 8 months ago

Could you also include which version and any modules you're using?

image

Rafynwolf commented 8 months ago

image

Modules loaded - Dice so nice (4.6.8) and Dice Tray (1.4.2)

Rafynwolf commented 8 months ago

Also just noticed that when I refresh and the roll results appear I see the below. As polearms is rated at 0 should this not be a single dice plus str. stat? This looks to be 2 dice + str.

image

VacantFanatic commented 8 months ago

Ok so:

For the # of dice it turns out a skill roll is actually (Success die + a number of dice equal to the skill (zero in this case) + an additional die). I had thought it was just the skill pool as well when I had first set it up :-)

Thank you for checking though! :-)

image

Rafynwolf commented 8 months ago

Thanks. I can confirm that after deactivating DsN results appear.
Apologies for mistake on the skill roll. I read that about 4 times before posting, and still got it wrong ;o) I then reread another 3 times after reading your reply. Yes. success dice plus skill rank, + 1. :o)

Would it be ok for me to make some suggestions for later enhancements? If so, could I suggest the below: 1 - Make Success dice identifiable as separate line in results (minor as in meantime would just say top result was success dice but a nice addition) 2 - leading on from 1, when integrated with DSN make the success dice to be modified separate from other dice so it can appear as a different colour. 3 - Allow target number to be added prior to roll, 4 - leading on from 3 - display results to indicate success/fail and additional successes etc.

Many thanks.

VacantFanatic commented 8 months ago

No worries and please suggest away! 1 - I'm aiming to do something like this when I do the roll card. Have a PNG of a Black die with the total # on one row followed by a white die (dice) PNG on a separate line for the skill dice. (Part of the roll cards mentioned above). 2 - Agreed I'd like the same to happen in DSN (Black die plus white skill - round two would see those colors customizable) 3 - This one I'm on the fence about. Ranged rolls make sense. Melee is more difficult due to the contested nature. For skill rolls as a GM I'm not fond of this. I'd rather ask for the roll and narrate the result. The player doesn't need to know the DV. 4 - Again this moves the needle to far to the "video game" side IMHO. I'd rather leave it to the GM to determine degree of success and narrate.