Incompatibility with worldgen mods (Tectonic + Wyther's Expanded Ecosphere)<title>

[alejandrorusso4]

Mod Name

Tectonic, Expanded Ecosphere

This issue occurs when only Valkyrien Skies, addons, and the mod I have specified are installed and no other mods

• [X] I have tested this issue and it occurs with only Valkyrien Skies, addons, and the mod I have specified

Minecraft Version

1.20.x

Mod Loader

Fabric

Issue description

When Tectonic, WWOO, or both mods are installed, assembling a ship causes it to disappear (sometimes). More mods makes the probability of this higher. I tested it with just Tectonic and just WWOO and the ship would assemble fine the first couple of times, then disappear immediately after clicking on Assemble.

Also, not sure how related this is but on the debug stats it says the VS PhysTPS is 0, when it should be 60

Issue reproduction

Install VS and addons, install Tectonic. Config enable "increased_height":true. Install Expanded Ecospheres. Build and assemble ship

Logs

No response

[Syclusion]

My guess would be it is trying to assemble a GIANT ship based on the extra worldgen (hence why its seemingly randomized bc of the variance of terrain) maybe limiting worldgen to a specific height in the shipyard could fix it?

[alejandrorusso4]

It does seem to be a world height issue. Worldgen mods with vanilla world height get this issue less frequently than those that increase the build height dramatically

[PriestOfFerns]

I think this is just an issue with vs2 1.20 being buggy, No relation to world gen mods. An easy way to prove that would be to look at 1.18, where this issue never happens, despite having more or less the same mods

[Syclusion]

I think this is just an issue with vs2 1.20 being buggy, No relation to world gen mods. An easy way to prove that would be to look at 1.18, where this issue never happens, despite having more or less the same mods

Considering I've been using 1.20 for awhile now and have had no issues like this. It's doubtful lol. I tried changing the settings in tectonic and instantly ran into this crash. It's 100% worldgen being screwed up

[PriestOfFerns]

@Syclusion did the ship you assembled have wings on it

[Syclusion]

@Syclusion did the ship you assembled have wings on it

No. Was a piece of wanderlight ore being interacted with.

[PriestOfFerns]

I'd be surprised if tectonic somehow caused issues with VS2 ships, and only on 1.20.1, but ig it's possible.

Either way most of this is anecdotal and not really reproducible. And tectonic is popular enough that most modpacks include it, so it's quite hard to blame it specifically

[Syclusion]

I'd be surprised if tectonic somehow caused issues with VS2 ships, and only on 1.20.1, but ig it's possible.

Either way most of this is anecdotal and not really reproducible. And tectonic is popular enough that most modpacks include it, so it's quite hard to blame it specifically

Change the config and it'll happen. Took 3 minutes to reproduce, this isn't stock tectonic the config matters.

[Syclusion]

It's less tectonic being at fault and more vs2 being unable to account for generation beyond default values imho

[alejandrorusso4]

It also occurs when changing world height/messing with settings with ReTerraforged On Jun 27, 2024 at 5:29 PM -0400, Syclusion @.***>, wrote:

It's less tectonic being at fault and more vs2 being unable to account for generation beyond default values imho — Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or unsubscribe. You are receiving this because you authored the thread.Message ID: @.***>

[PriestOfFerns]

It's less tectonic being at fault and more vs2 being unable to account for generation beyond default values imho

"Vs2 being unable to account for generation beyond default values" usually just leads to terrain generating in the shipyard, causing ships to be made with entire chunks of terrain on them, not ships disappearing somehow.

Either way 1.20 VS2 has it's own large share of bugs, a lot of which can easily lead to ships "disappearing" (Example), so I find it a bit tough to believe that it has something to do with terrain generation mods, which already work on 1.18. At the very least you need a list of what config values cause issues, rather than just "something in config breaks mod", in order to verify this as an issue and get it fixed

[Syclusion]

It's less tectonic being at fault and more vs2 being unable to account for generation beyond default values imho

"Vs2 being unable to account for generation beyond default values" usually just leads to terrain generating in the shipyard, causing ships to be made with entire chunks of terrain on them, not ships disappearing somehow.

Either way 1.20 VS2 has it's own large share of bugs, a lot of which can easily lead to ships "disappearing" (Example), so I find it a bit tough to believe that it has something to do with terrain generation mods, which already work on 1.18. At the very least you need a list of what config values cause issues, rather than just "something in config breaks mod", in order to verify this as an issue and get it fixed

They aren't disappearing, vs2 tps tanks and crashes the client because it's doing exactly that, trying to assemble giant chunks of terrain

[Syclusion]

Also he already provided the config value that breaks it lol.

increased_height:true in tectonic

[AgentMelinda]

?

[thetheaplant]

? @AgentMelinda The issue and what breaks it is well explained, what further information do you need