search

VasylBaran / CommandShift

CommandShift allows you change input source (in MacOS) using Windows-style shortcuts
GNU General Public License v3.0
94 stars 0 forks source link

ARM version is not working on a a1 max #1

Closed avi-stx closed 2 years ago

avi-stx commented 2 years ago

ARM version is not working on a a1 max

VasylBaran commented 2 years ago

ARM version is not working on a a1 max

Could you explain in more detail? Are you getting some error message? And could also mention your MacOS version? Thanks

unickq commented 2 years ago

m1 pro

image image
VasylBaran commented 2 years ago

m1 pro

image image

Ah, that's probably because I used Big Sur to compile the app. I'll get a copy of Monterey and re-compile CommandShift in the coming days. Thanks for reporting the issue, btw! ;-)

VasylBaran commented 2 years ago

UPDATE: I've just upgraded to Monterey and the current version of CommandShift still runs fine. After googling the issue I've reasized that it's most likely due to Security settings. The following solution should help:

Navigate to System Preferences, select Security and Privacy, and go to General. Go to Allow apps downloaded from and select Anywhere. In other words, you’re allowing non-App Store apps to run on your machine.

Please let me know if it helped. Cheers! ;-)

unickq commented 2 years ago

@VasylBaran

image

sudo spctl --master-disable allows it, but doesn't help much

image
VasylBaran commented 2 years ago

UPDATE: sorry, my bad. You're absolutely right, ARM64 app was damaged and now I've uploded a new version - please give it a try and let me know if everything is ok. Thank you! ;-)

BEGEMOT9I commented 2 years ago

@VasylBaran Hi! I've tried current version on M1 Pro and it still not working by the same reason (warning about damaged app) :(

anorudes commented 2 years ago

Yep, it's not working on m1 :'(

VasylBaran commented 2 years ago

@BEGEMOT9I @anorudes @avirosenberg @unickq ok, so this is very weird... When I use CommandShift.app from dmg-image that I just created locally - it works fine. But after uploading it to Bitbucket/SourceForge/GitHub and downloading it again - the CommandShift.app becomes "damaged" o_O

This is strange, some permissions issue perhaps?

UPDATE: ok, the problem is that MacOS marks my app as damaged even though it isn't. I'll figure out how to solve it properly so that people won't have to hassle with this in the future but in the mean time if you want CommandShift to work right now - here's a temporary solution:

Please run this command in Terminal (it recursively removes all attributes from app-file) xattr -cr /Applications/CommandShift.app

P.S. just wanted to say 'thank you!' for trying out CommandShift so early on, it's my first release of a desktop app on GitHub and your feedback is very important because without it I wouldn't even know about this issue since it worked fine on my side. So thanks again! I'll keep you updated... ;-)

BEGEMOT9I commented 2 years ago

@VasylBaran Hi again! I tried your solution, it works, the application starts normally, but changing the language by pressing any of the combinations, that are in the list, still does not work. If you want, you can write to me in TG (@BEGEMOT9I) and try to debug together)

VasylBaran commented 2 years ago

@VasylBaran Hi again! I tried your solution, it works, the application starts normally, but changing the language by pressing any of the combinations, that are in the list, still does not work. If you want, you can write to me in TG (@BEGEMOT9I) and try to debug together)

ok, and did you add CommandShift to "Security & Privacy -> Privacy -> Accessibility" ?

BEGEMOT9I commented 2 years ago

Yeah)

VasylBaran commented 2 years ago

@BEGEMOT9I ok, and the last question: do you have system level shortcuts to change language set to default like on this screenshot?

Screenshot 2022-02-20 at 14 06 36
BEGEMOT9I commented 2 years ago

Not exactly, for "previous input source" i have cmd + space

BEGEMOT9I commented 2 years ago

Ooo, i've got it) Yeah, with default ctrl+space this app is working well 👍 I think it must be described in README in order to avoid misunderstanding

VasylBaran commented 2 years ago

Ooo, i've got it) Yeah, with default ctrl+space this app is working well 👍 I think it must be described in README in order to avoid misunderstanding

I'm glad it worked for you. Yes, you're right - I'll update the README. Thanks again! ;-)

BEGEMOT9I commented 2 years ago

Ooo, i've got it) Yeah, with default ctrl+space this app is working well 👍 I think it must be described in README in order to avoid misunderstanding

I'm glad it worked for you. Yes, you're right - I'll update the README. Thanks again! ;-)

I think info about changing app attributes would also be useful to describe)

Ramlevy commented 2 years ago

xattr -cr /Applications/CommandShift.app @VasylBaran Had the exact same problem and this solved it! Thanks a bunch.

VasylBaran commented 2 years ago

xattr -cr /Applications/CommandShift.app @VasylBaran Had the exact same problem and this solved it! Thanks a bunch.

I'm glad it worked for you. I plan to find a better solution (so that people wouldn't be getting this error message at all). But I'm not sure when this will happen since I'm from Ukraine and currently it's a warzone here. Can't believe I'm writing this, 4 months in and it's still feels surreal...

VasylBaran commented 2 years ago

Ok, the problem is that MacOS marks my app as damaged even though it isn't. I'll figure out how to solve it properly so that people won't have to hassle with this in the future, but I'm not sure when this will happen since I'm from Ukraine and currently it's a warzone here. Can't believe I'm writing this, 4 months in and it's still feels surreal...

Anyhow, in the mean time if you want CommandShift to work right now - here's a temporary solution:

Please run this command in Terminal (it recursively removes all attributes from app-file) xattr -cr /Applications/CommandShift.app

P.S. I would also like to say 'thank you!' for trying out CommandShift so early on, it's my first release of a desktop app on GitHub and your feedback priceless. So thanks again, you're awesome! Peace! ;-)