VazkiiMods / Botania

A tech mod for Minecraft themed around the magic of nature and plant life.
http://botaniamod.net/index.html
Other
1.26k stars 506 forks source link

Tangleberrie does not affect Enderman #2085

Closed 7OOTnegaTerces closed 4 years ago

7OOTnegaTerces commented 7 years ago

I tried setting up an enderman farm with an EnderIO powered spawner, a Tangleberrie, a Bellethorne, and a Vinculotus. However, while the Bellethorne and Vinculotus work as advertised, the Tangleberry doesn't do jack for keeping the endermen inside the trap. Having used the manaseer monocle it is clear that the Tangleberrie plant does not work on enderman which, baring clarification to it's entry in the Lexica, it should.

TheWhiteWolves commented 7 years ago

are the endermen teleporting out or are they walking away?

7OOTnegaTerces commented 7 years ago

Walking away (the Vinculotus is working just fine for yanking them back whenever they try to teleport away).

TheWhiteWolves commented 7 years ago

any chance u could get a small video or gif of it, particularly looking at the endermen, need to see if the sparkle effect is happening

7OOTnegaTerces commented 7 years ago

Sorry it took me so long to reply, I've been sick! I just tried to recreate the setup I'd been using in a blank test world and the Enderman are now reacting to the Tangleberrie as if it's a Bellethorne. At first I wondered if it had always been like this and I just hadn't been able to tell since I'd always had the Bellethorne active. But then I remembered noticing that the Bellethorne could only affect one mob at a time whereas now all the Enderman within the Tangleberrie's area of affect were being harmed. Thus something had definitely changed. So then I went back to my original world and recreated the old setup (when I'd planned on fencing the Enderman in with the Tangleberrie. This did work as expected (no Enderman were harmed by the Tangleberrie), or at least, exactly as I expect it to not work. The Enderman seem to almost notice the Tangleberries boundary, but they are able to cross it with only a slight pause, as my accompanying GIF shows. And no, I never noticed any sparkle effect.

On a side note, it would be REALLY helpful for special plants like the Tangleberrie and Jiyuulia if there was some sort of particle effect always active that showed the player exactly where the boundary of their effect is. The monocle is great and all, but it only shows that boundary if you're staring at the plant, and from relatively closely. Not only does this mean that you can only view the boundary opposite to your position, and from some distance away, but it means that you actually have to come within the plant's area of effect, which puts you INSIDE the lion's cage in the case of the Tangleberrie, in order to inspect it's bars. That's really NOT useful, AT ALL. Even in creative mode, it was still difficult to keep the Enderman and the Tangleberrie in my sight for the GIF I made so it was clear exactly when they walked over it's boundary. On the other hand, with some sort of boundary particle effect, a player could confidently walk just inside (or outside) that boundary without ever worrying about crossing it and getting eaten.

enderman and tangleberrie a enderman and tangleberrie b

TheWhiteWolves commented 7 years ago

if there's no sparkle effects then the tangleberrie is probably not affecting them, I'd load up MC and check myself but my system is unable to load it without crashing straight away anymore. 😛

TJOak commented 7 years ago

In case you didn't know, if you bind your Wand of the Forest to a flower while wearing the monocle, you can see the range without looking directly at the flower.

williewillus commented 7 years ago

cannot reproduce, it keeps endermen in fine in my test world (vanilla endermen though)

actually just saw it happen, nvm

williewillus commented 7 years ago

it seems like whatever the flower applies isn't "strong enough" to keep it in

TheWhiteWolves commented 7 years ago

iirc it works similar to how we built the attractors back in thaumic tinkerer, it just pushes back against the mob with the velocity it is trying to move at, but vaz may have changed it since then, i'd have to look at the code.

github-actions[bot] commented 4 years ago

This issue is stale because it has been open for a while with no activity. Remove stale label or comment or this will be closed soon.