search

ViaVersion / ViaFabric

Client-side and server-side ViaVersion implementation for Fabric
https://viaversion.com/fabric
GNU General Public License v3.0
323 stars 38 forks source link

Fails on e4mc and Essential regardless of client-side modes #247

Closed Kichura closed 8 months ago

Kichura commented 1 year ago

/viaversion dump Output

https://dump.viaversion.com/98fd26684595cf16bd6a36c39d498ca4051e74a659e32010566748775b1c82bb

Console Error

(No console errors were discovered during tests)

Bug Description

When opening the singleplayer to LAN whilst ViaFabric is deployed - Players are able to join properly using the required extensions that the server owner has also included in their modpack(s) which is ViaBackwards and optionally ViaRewind,

However when combining it with e4mc / essential mod, Both will cancel out ViaFabric's translation attempts and instead fallback to vanilla's "Outdated Client!" behavior instead.

Steps to Reproduce

  1. Get a 1.19.4 client and 1.18.2 client respectively,
  2. Deploy ViaFabric, ViaBackwards and either e4mc or essential mod onto the 1.19.4 client,
  3. Open any world on the 1.19.4 client and request it to be opened to LAN,
  4. Attempt to join the server using 1.18.2 client by using e4mc's IP or essential's friends system,
  5. Expect a kick from there.

Expected Behavior

ViaFabric is able to communicate with e4mc and essential mod properly and continues translating.

Additional Server Info

  1. The server is not running on a proxy,
  2. Two tests were platformed so far:

ViaFabric, ViaBackwards with e4mc, and same thing again as above but instead essential mod was used.

  1. Client-Side was active during these attempts.

Checklist

Kichura commented 1 year ago

Something else i will have to point out in this entire issue:

  1. Essential mod is entirely closed-source, meaning it will be difficult to troubleshoot this mod due to how complicated it is,
  2. e4mc is open source but on dedicated GitTea instance, But this one reveals a generated sub-domain upon opening to LAN.
cootshk commented 1 year ago

try using world host

Make sure to open mod menu config and turn off try Upnp

Kichura commented 1 year ago

try using world host

Make sure to open mod menu config and turn off try Upnp

This mod works properly without issues during testing.

Kichura commented 8 months ago

Since these two mods essentially use a different method for connectivity, will not be fixed.