VizierDB / web-api-async

Vizier Asynchronous Web API
Apache License 2.0
2 stars 2 forks source link

Support for accounts #14

Closed okennedy closed 4 years ago

okennedy commented 5 years ago

It's boring, but if people are going to use this we need at least a limited ability to perform data governance tools. Basic HTTP Authentication works, but is decidedly all-or-nothing.

mrb24 commented 5 years ago

A few points that came up at SIGMOD about governance:

okennedy commented 5 years ago

@lordpretzel @julianafreire @heikomuller @soniacq

Given the strong call for it at SIGMOD, it would be worth starting to think about how we would go about implementing this. It seems like a pretty substantial change, so I'd like to have a head-to-head at some point to figure out how exactly this is going to be implemented.

julianafreire commented 5 years ago

These are important features. However, IMHO we should first make sure that we have a single-user tool that is easy-to-use, effective for different (and representative) use-cases, and scalable.

okennedy commented 5 years ago

I agree that ease-of-use and effectiveness for specific use cases have to come first. However, I think you're getting at a deeper question: How do we expect individual users to interact with Vizier. Almost since the start of the project we've been using a tiered design (UI / API / Mimir) that is not really ideal for non-technical users to set up and run. In general, that's been ok, because nowadays most people seem to be looking for hosted tools anyway (in particular if their org can self-host), but this is a deeper discussion: Are we building a hosted tool, or a desktop application?

Hosted

Desktop

okennedy commented 4 years ago

Moving this issue out of Vizier core.