VlachosGroup / pMuTT

Python Multiscale Thermochemistry Toolbox (pMuTT)
https://vlachosgroup.github.io/pMuTT/
39 stars 21 forks source link

Chemkin_IO Example #61

Closed SidraFirdous closed 5 years ago

SidraFirdous commented 5 years ago

Dear Authors,

Thank you for this software.

I am trying to reproduce your example of "Ammonia Synthesis" microkinetics, as listed in: "https://github.com/VlachosGroup/pMuTT/blob/master/docs/source/examples_jupyter/chemkin_io/"

I have a few questions regarding this example:

  1. I see that "NH3 desorption" is actually listed as NH3 adsorption in the cell "A5" of the reactions sheet of the excel sheet of https://github.com/VlachosGroup/pMuTT/blob/master/docs/source/examples_jupyter/chemkin_io/inputs/NH3_Input_Data.xlsx, My question is how exactly are the adsorption and desorption rate constants calculated?

  2. In this example, the energies in the cell H6 to H15 are the energies of the respective species on the surface (Ru0001) slab?

  3. In the list of vibrational wave numbers, we don't include the imaginary frequencies of the ts or the ground states. Is that right?

Thanks.

jonlym commented 5 years ago

Hi @SidraFirdous,

Thank you for your interest.

  1. This module was developed with the Vlachos' groups in-house Chemkin code so there may be differences when compared to Chemkin Pro. We calculate adsorption rate constants using Equation 56 in the Chemkin III manual. The reverse rate constant (calculated by Chemkin and not pMuTT) can be found using Equation 36.

  2. The energies have the slab contribution subtracted (i.e. E = E(slab + ads) - E(slab)). This is ultimately bookkeeping as we initialized our E(slab) to be 0.

  3. If you include imaginary frequencies (as negative numbers), by default the vibrational modes will store them but ultimately ignore them when evaluating thermochemical properties.

Does that address your issue?

SidraFirdous commented 5 years ago

Dear Jonathan, Thank you for the quick answers to my questions. They are up to the point and answer what I asked.

Thanks.

jonlym commented 5 years ago
  1. It is not open domain.

  2. It is enough because all reactions are assumed to be reversible.

  3. I'm unsure since I do not have any experience with Chemkin-Pro.

  4. H/RT is the dimensionless enthalpy and not heat capacity. The NIST estimate for heat of formation of NH3 is -45.94 kJ/mol. Using R = 8.314e-3 kJ/mol/K and T = 298.15, you get a value of -18.53. (We'll have to update the example to match that).