search

VocaDB / community

https://vocadb.net
0 stars 0 forks source link

Allow mapping tags to artists #176

Closed riipah closed 1 year ago

riipah commented 5 years ago

For example, if the Nico song is tagged with "Hatsune Miku", prefill "Hatsune Miku" as an artist to song on VocaDB. Currently, only title and uploader are used to prefill artists.

Is it enough to do the mapping based on artist name 1:1? Or do we need configurable mapping? Should we only consider locked tags?

Shiroizu commented 5 years ago

Some edge cases:

  1. Character appears in the PV but is not a vocalist.
  2. Incorrect tagging

1:1 mapping seems good enough, since most of the time the vocalist is Miku. Since the title & artist prefills can't be 100% accurate, it shouldn't matter if nico sometimes suggests wrong vocalists. At the moment with the title prefill, it's still user's responsibility to validate it. The added convenience outweighs the possible errors.

riipah commented 5 years ago

It reads the NND tags. Then sees that VocaDB also got the tag mapped to an artist.

Sounds like you're talking about explicit configurable tag mapping. That is more complicated than just mapping by name.

What Shiroizu was suggesting is, "Hatsune Miku" tag will be mapped to "Hatsune Miku" artist by using the artist name, there is no tag configuration, which makes it more simple, but inflexible.

Also, the tag mappings for Vocaloids etc. could be somehow locked so that nobody mapping them wrong

Are you talking about configuring the mappings, if there is explicit mapping?

No, I don't think it's a problem. Tag mapping configuration is only available to moderators, and some others.

github-actions[bot] commented 1 year ago

This issue is stale because it has been open 7 days with no activity. Remove stale label or comment or this will be closed in 7 days.