Closed dury10 closed 2 months ago
dury10
commented
3 months ago Here is a live stream with details how to asamble the toolhead https://www.youtube.com/live/S5xbkWCNOBw?si=QTv8fzixqjN_HTtS
and here is a video with the Toolhead in action https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hGzCLkhoCfY
Regarding the if was tested.
this toolhead was on a heavy load/test in the last 6 months
bdbell
commented
3 months ago dury10
commented
3 months ago
Can you please explain how this is different than a stretched Mini-Afterburner with some covers? This Toolhead it has better part cooling it uses 2x 4010 It has 2 Neopixel LED lights for improved visibility and real-time print status updates It has pasive cooling for the nema14 stepper motor A lot of covers as you said with built in cable management.
The description sounds like marketing but does not actually describe what the mod is. Please update. The description it has a clear key features and it says that it is a Toolhead, an alternative for what it exist already.
The readme absolutely cannot have a PayPal link or any mention of donations to you. I have removed the link.
dury10
commented
3 months ago I have corrected the orientation and the yml file. Regarding the step file I have made an achieve and it cannot be less than 4mb @MapleLeafMakers any suggestions?
MapleLeafMakers
commented
3 months ago I have corrected the orientation and the yml file. Regarding the step file I have made an achieve and it cannot be less than 4mb @MapleLeafMakers any suggestions?
4MB is no problem, you can remove the 7z version though, just the .stp is fine
dury10
commented
3 months ago I have corrected the orientation and the yml file. Regarding the step file I have made an achieve and it cannot be less than 4mb @MapleLeafMakers any suggestions?
4MB is no problem, you can remove the 7z version though, just the .stp is fine
Ok i have removed the 7z file
dury10
commented
2 months ago
@MapleLeafMakers did I miss enything?
github-actions[bot]
commented
2 months ago Hi, thank you for submitting your PR. Please find below the results of the automated PR checker:
| Item | Result | Description/Error | Printer compatibility/Error Detail |
|---|---|---|---|
| dury10/Spartacus | ✅ SUCCESS | Spartacus The Toolhead | V2.4r2, VT |
| Tool | ✅ | ⚠️ | ❌ | 💀 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| STL corruption checker | 22 | |||
| File checker | 148 | 1 | ||
| Readme generator | 1 | |||
| Mod structure checker | ||||
| STL rotation checker | 22 |
](https://ik.imagekit.io/vorondesign/ci_1046/shutter_cbzMBEkF.png) | |
| strain_relief_45_degres_cover.stl | ✅ SUCCESS | [
](https://ik.imagekit.io/vorondesign/ci_1046/strain_relief_45_degres_cover_bqJJBxhu.png) | |
| MGN12_6mmBelt_X_carriage_Left.stl | ✅ SUCCESS | [
](https://ik.imagekit.io/vorondesign/ci_1046/MGN12_6mmBelt_X_carriage_Left_lpcXSckI.png) | |
| idler.stl | ✅ SUCCESS | [
](https://ik.imagekit.io/vorondesign/ci_1046/idler_IYFzxphN.png) | |
| extruder_back_plate.stl | ✅ SUCCESS | [
](https://ik.imagekit.io/vorondesign/ci_1046/extruder_back_plate_rREvzhaH.png) | |
| stepper_motor_cover.stl | ✅ SUCCESS | [
](https://ik.imagekit.io/vorondesign/ci_1046/stepper_motor_cover_KEGAmIEi.png) | |
| strain_relief_45_degres.stl | ✅ SUCCESS | [
](https://ik.imagekit.io/vorondesign/ci_1046/strain_relief_45_degres_WxcBniqr.png) | |
| belt_holder_x2.stl | ✅ SUCCESS | [
](https://ik.imagekit.io/vorondesign/ci_1046/belt_holder_x2_fzlerxLU.png) | |
| strain_relief_90_degres_cover.stl | ✅ SUCCESS | [
](https://ik.imagekit.io/vorondesign/ci_1046/strain_relief_90_degres_cover_ukQvhWBg.png) | |
| latch.stl | ✅ SUCCESS | [
](https://ik.imagekit.io/vorondesign/ci_1046/latch_OUQrsUNF.png) | |
| strain_relief_90_degres.stl | ✅ SUCCESS | [
](https://ik.imagekit.io/vorondesign/ci_1046/strain_relief_90_degres_xXWXoPcH.png) | |
| ebb_36_can_cover.stl | ✅ SUCCESS | [
](https://ik.imagekit.io/vorondesign/ci_1046/ebb_36_can_cover_xeIvZgFt.png) | |
| rapido_holder_front.stl | ✅ SUCCESS | [
](https://ik.imagekit.io/vorondesign/ci_1046/rapido_holder_front_YLXEJhUq.png) | |
| V6_holder_front.stl | ✅ SUCCESS | [
](https://ik.imagekit.io/vorondesign/ci_1046/V6_holder_front_kVJCUJxi.png) | |
| v6_holder_back.stl | ✅ SUCCESS | [
](https://ik.imagekit.io/vorondesign/ci_1046/v6_holder_back_QpOuyXJo.png) | |
| MGN12_6mmBelt_X_carriage_Right.stl | ✅ SUCCESS | [
](https://ik.imagekit.io/vorondesign/ci_1046/MGN12_6mmBelt_X_carriage_Right_AdwNTlIK.png) | |
| rapido_holder_back.stl | ✅ SUCCESS | [
](https://ik.imagekit.io/vorondesign/ci_1046/rapido_holder_back_bMigrQRU.png) | |
| extruder_main_body.stl | ✅ SUCCESS | [
](https://ik.imagekit.io/vorondesign/ci_1046/extruder_main_body_bjVBRvnn.png) | |
| klicky_dock.stl | ✅ SUCCESS | [
](https://ik.imagekit.io/vorondesign/ci_1046/klicky_dock_wBDRrsqW.png) | |
| klicky.stl | ✅ SUCCESS | [
](https://ik.imagekit.io/vorondesign/ci_1046/klicky_eokATZkZ.png) | |
| Klicky_holder.stl | ✅ SUCCESS | [
](https://ik.imagekit.io/vorondesign/ci_1046/Klicky_holder_SmGRUaXm.png) | |
| Spartacus_Face.stl | ✅ SUCCESS | [
](https://ik.imagekit.io/vorondesign/ci_1046/Spartacus_Face_spqRpeDj.png) | |
---
I am a 🤖, this comment was generated automatically!
Made with ❤️ by the VoronDesign GitHub Team
FHeilmann
commented
2 months ago @dury10 Thanks for submitting this mod. After some internal discussion I have decided to reject this mod. Please find my explanation below:
Spartacus is a very complex mod to the VoronDesign 3D printer ecosystem. A lot of configurations and different variants are supported. As a result, this will likely cause the community to have a lot of feature requests and also may find some bugs while using it. You may wish to incorporate these features or fix these bugs. VoronUsers is not equipped to handle such development as feature requests and bugfixes (beyond simple things) are out of scope here.
Here is my suggestion: Put Spartacus into its own github repository. This has the following advantages:
I'm sorry it has taken me this long to come to this conclusion, especially since you have already put a lot of work in to fix the concerns the other reviewers (and our CI) have had with the mod.
I look forward to seing Spartacus get the exposure it deserves, and the possibility of it becoming an established alternative for toolheads in the Voron printer ecosystem.
If you have any further questions, please reach out to me on discord (Haribro)
Sorry again, and best of luck
Florian (Haribro)
Which mods are added by this PR?
How was it tested?
Any background context you want to provide?
Screenshots (if appropriate)
⚠️⚠️PLEASE READ AND COMPLETE THE CHECKLIST BELOW⚠️⚠️