Open HumbleDeer opened 1 year ago
Great idea overall and allows for a more clutter-free RCSC setup for example.
Let's leave out the pin setup for the driver fans, as they are supposed to be connected to the stepper driver directly in a typical setup; however we can of course provide a commented-out example plus documentation in the printer.cfg
we provide.
This could tie in nicely with some suggestions as well as ideas I took over from the guys over at mellow-3d.github.io.
The way they have their config files modular for each motherboard is not only a great idea, but a fantastic resource right out of the gate. This would solve issues like the one Nero had, where he had to redo his whole config cause the pin diagram we provide is a different board type than the one he got.
I agree with Nero that we should be supplying config files for all possible configurations that the Mellow kit could come in. The modular way of working would really help with editing the configs on the user side of things as well.
See this: https://mellow-3d.github.io/fly_super8_klipper_mcu_config.html#fly-super8-aliases-file
That's nice if you're a vendor with a limited set of boards that are fully under your control, but it gets out of hand fast if we have to support printers * boards
pin aliases and matching configurations. That isn't to say we can't provide a set of pin alias stubs plus reference configuration files for the most popular boards out there, thinking of:
I'm not suggesting we support all boards. I suggest we support the three versions of Mellow board we talk about in the docs. Those are the ones that make sense, as they're the ones the kits and BOM have.
It would also make sense to actually rename the printer configs printer-vz235awd.cfg for example, or other verbose and descriptive terms in both the titles and the file inside.
But @pbsuper told me to keep mn fikken van de printer configs :')
Proposal: use [multi_pin xxx] in config files
Make use of some multi_pin aliases and/or controller_fan definitions to control fans otherwise controlled by different pins.
There's multiple parts of the printer where multiple accessories are controlled as one device. For example:
Not fans, but also possible to control in groups (provided pins are set up correctly):
Aux fans / RSCS fans
Reference:
https://www.klipper3d.org/Config_Reference.html#multi_pin
Example:
Exhaust fans
Vz235 has two smaller exhaust fans instead of the Vz330's single larger fan. These can be combined using a multi_pin alias as well.
Stepper driver fans
Configuring the stepper driver fans to be driven by four fan ports on the motherboard
Reference:
https://www.klipper3d.org/Config_Reference.html#multi_pin https://www.klipper3d.org/Config_Reference.html#controller_fan
Partially courtesy of @AxMod3DPrint