search

W3C-HCLSIG / HCLSDatasetDescriptions

7 stars 13 forks source link

Creator and date rules #118

Closed AlasdairGray closed 9 years ago

AlasdairGray commented 9 years ago

When adding the description column, we have changed the requirements for what properties must be provided and may be provided for declaring authorship and dates associated with a dataset. Is this intentional? Previously pav terms were may and dct terms were must.

AlasdairGray commented 9 years ago

This has affects for the validation of documents

AlasdairGray commented 9 years ago

Same applies to Source Provenance

micheldumontier commented 9 years ago

I don't believe that source provenance was a must.

AlasdairGray commented 9 years ago

No, but I believe some were should and some were may, although I have not verified. There is also a consequence of presenting them this way from a validation point of view. By reading the logical or it is assumed that if one of them is present then the category is satisfied.

mscottm commented 9 years ago

Is the question whether to require at least dct and allow pav terms vs allow either or both dct and pav terms in the validator?