search

W3C-HCLSIG / HCLSDatasetDescriptions

7 stars 13 forks source link

sd:namedGraph #82

Closed AlasdairGray closed 9 years ago

AlasdairGray commented 9 years ago

In the table we recommend the use of sd:namedGraph for stating the named graphs in the RDF distribution of a dataset.

What is the meaning of the Value column for this attribute which is set to sd:NamedGraph? Do we mean that the corresponding value of this triple is an IRI and that resource is typed as a sd:NamedGraph?

There is no corresponding text in Section 6.6.1, i.e. there is no example usage of this property.

KimJBaran commented 9 years ago

I think we mean that the value is an IRI and that the resource is a sd:NamedGraph instance. We have other values that I would interpret this way, however, we should be clearer on that and avoid to leave it to the reader to figure out the meaning that we intend to convey.

AlasdairGray commented 9 years ago

That is what I thought as well. We should change the value in the table to be consistent with the other properties of this type. That is, we should change the value to either an IRI or [a sd:NamedGraph].

KimJBaran commented 9 years ago

I second that motion and I think we need to extend that to all related cases too.

AlasdairGray commented 9 years ago

Specifically we need to correct the value column of