search

WCRP-CMIP / CMIP6_CVs

Controlled Vocabularies (CVs) for use in CMIP6
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International
155 stars 79 forks source link

source_id registration of BNU-ESM-1-1 #99

Closed melodyjulia closed 6 years ago

melodyjulia commented 7 years ago 
label = BNU-ESM 1.1
source_id = BNU-ESM-1-1
institution_id = BNU
release_year = 2016

label_extended = BNU-ESM 1.1
aerosol = unnamed
atmosphere = CAM4
atmospheric_chemistry = unnamed
land_ice = None
land_surface = CoLM
ocean = MOM4p1
ocean_biogeochemistry = unnamed
sea_ice = CICE4.1
durack1 commented 7 years ago

@duoying I am just trying to finalise this, do you have some additional information that you wanted to add in below (specified by # entries below - sample text in () are taken from the CMIP5 contributing model ACCESS-1-0)?

        "BNU-ESM-1-1":{
            "aerosol":"unnamed", # Is there a version number or further info
            "atmosphere":"CAM4", # Is there additional information available i.e (r1.1; 192 x 145 N96; 38 levels; top level 39255m) or similar?
            "atmospheric_chemistry":"unnamed", # Is there a version number or further info
            "cohort":[
                ""
            ],
            "institution_id":[
                "BNU"
            ],
            "label":"BNU-ESM 1.1",
            "label_extended":"BNU-ESM 1.1",
            "land_ice":"None",
            "land_surface":"CoLM", # Is there a version number or further info
            "ocean":"MOM4p1", # is there additional information available i.e (MOM4p1; tripolar primarily 1deg latitude/longitude; 50 levels; top grid cell 0-10m)
            "ocean_biogeochemistry":"unnamed", # Is there a version number or further info
            "release_year":"2016",
            "sea_ice":"CICE4.1",
            "source_id":"BNU-ESM-1-1"
},
melodyjulia commented 7 years ago

@durack1 we revised to the following form:

    "BNU-ESM-1-1":{
        "aerosol":"CAM-chem",
        "atmosphere":"CAM4 (FV 144x96; 26 levels)",
        "atmospheric_chemistry":"CAM-chem",
        "cohort":[
            ""
        ],
        "institution_id":[
            "BNU"
        ],
        "label":"BNU-ESM 1.1",
        "label_extended":"BNU-ESM 1.1",
        "land_ice":"None",
        "land_surface":"CoLM with carbon-nitrogen interactions",
        "ocean":"MOM4p1 (360x200, tripolar, primarily 1deg latitude/longitude, down to 1/3deg  within 30deg of the equatorial tropics; 50 levels)
        "ocean_biogeochemistry":"Dynamic ecosystem-carbon model"
        "release_year":"2016",
        "sea_ice":"CICE4.1",
        "source_id":"BNU-ESM-1-1"

}

durack1 commented 7 years ago

@duoying great I'll start pulling this across.. Just because I am interested do you have some additional information for the ??UPPERCASE?? fields below, and version numbers for the specific modules noted below?

        "BNU-ESM-1-1":{
            "aerosol":"CAM-chem", # Is there a version number
            "atmosphere":"CAM4 (FV 144x96; 26 levels, ??TOP LEVEL: XXMB??)",
            "atmospheric_chemistry":"CAM-chem", # Is there a version number
            "land_surface":"CoLM with carbon-nitrogen interactions", # Is there a version number
            "ocean":"MOM4p1 (360x200, tripolar, primarily 1deg latitude/longitude, down to 1/3deg  within 30deg of the equatorial tropics; 50 levels, ??TOP [VERTICAL] LEVEL 0-10M??)
            "ocean_biogeochemistry":"Dynamic ecosystem-carbon model" # Is there a version number
}

If these are still being finalised, we can easily amend them in the future (before you start writing your data), however answering the questions below will allow for a more complete documentation of the model information

melodyjulia commented 7 years ago

@durack1 Please check the following revisions:

    "BNU-ESM-1-1":{
        "aerosol":"Semi-interactive",
        "atmosphere":"CAM4 (FV 144x96; 26 levels, TOP LEVEL: 2.194 MB)",
        "atmospheric_chemistry":"None", # It's turned off for CMIP6
        "land_surface":"CoLM with carbon-nitrogen interactions", # Is there a version number
        "ocean":"MOM4p1 (360x200, tripolar, primarily 1deg latitude/longitude, down to 1/3deg  within 30deg of the equatorial tropics; 50 levels, TOP 1 LEVEL 0-10M),
        "ocean_biogeochemistry":"Dynamic ecosystem-carbon model" # Is there a version number

}

durack1 commented 7 years ago

@duoying any chance you can provide an answer to the remaining queries so I can register your model?

"BNU-ESM-1-1":{
 "land_surface":"CoLM with carbon-nitrogen interactions", # Is there a version number
 "ocean_biogeochemistry":"Dynamic ecosystem-carbon model" # Is there a version number
}
melodyjulia commented 7 years ago

@durack1 please check the following revisions:

"BNU-ESM-1-1":{ "land_surface":"CoLM version 2014 with carbon-nitrogen interactions", # Is there a version number "ocean_biogeochemistry":"Dynamic ecosystem-carbon model version 1" # Is there a version number }

durack1 commented 7 years ago

@duoying please review the entries in CMIP6_source_id.html for accuracy, and if any revisions are required please reopen and detail the amendments in this issue

durack1 commented 7 years ago

@duoying we've amended the information that we're collecting about models and require some additional information from you. The values below need some revision or new information - I've noted ### some text ### below where I have revised the format between the # symbols, or a ### marker where web links to the information sources for new fields that we require additional information from you:

"BNU-ESM-1-1":{
  "activity_participation":[
    "" ### See activity list at https://github.com/WCRP-CMIP/CMIP6_CVs/blob/master/CMIP6_activity_id.json
  ],
  "atmosphere":"CAM4 (FV; ###144 x 96 longitude/latitude###; 26 levels; top level 2.194 mb)",
  "nominal_resolution_aerosol":"", ### See Appendix 2 in https://goo.gl/v1drZl ###
  "nominal_resolution_atmos":"",
  "nominal_resolution_land":"", 
  "nominal_resolution_ocean":"",
  "nominal_resolution_oceanBgchem":"",
  "nominal_resolution_seaIce":""
},
durack1 commented 7 years ago

@duoying have you had a chance to obtain the additional information we require above?

melodyjulia commented 7 years ago

@durack1 please see the following revisions:

"BNU-ESM-1-1":{ "activity_participation":[ "C4MIP","CMIP","GMMIP","GeoMIP","OMIP","ScenarioMIP" ], "atmosphere":"CAM4 (2deg; 144 x 96 longitude/latitude; 26 levels; top level 2.194 mb)", "nominal_resolution_aerosol":"250 km", "nominal_resolution_atmos":"250 km", "nominal_resolution_land":"250 km", "nominal_resolution_ocean":"100 km", "nominal_resolution_oceanBgchem":"100 km", "nominal_resolution_seaIce":"100 km" },

durack1 commented 7 years ago

@duoying thanks for this, peek at CMIP6_source_id.html and let me know if any further tweaks are required

melodyjulia commented 6 years ago

Dear @durack1 , I would like to revise the "activity_participation" of "BNU-ESM-1-1" as following:

"BNU-ESM-1-1":{ "activity_participation":[ "CMIP","C4MIP","CDRMIP","CFMIP","GMMIP","GeoMIP","OMIP","RFMIP","ScenarioMIP" ], "atmosphere":"CAM4 (2deg; 144 x 96 longitude/latitude; 26 levels; top level 2.194 mb)", "nominal_resolution_aerosol":"250 km", "nominal_resolution_atmos":"250 km", "nominal_resolution_land":"250 km", "nominal_resolution_ocean":"100 km", "nominal_resolution_oceanBgchem":"100 km", "nominal_resolution_seaIce":"100 km" },

durack1 commented 6 years ago

@duoying no problem, I will amend these details in the next update (and am re-opening this issue until the changes are in place)

durack1 commented 6 years ago

@duoying please review the updated details in CMIP6_source_id.html and let me know if any further tweaks are required