search

WICG / cq-usecases

Use cases and requirements for standardizing element queries.
Other
184 stars 24 forks source link

Use case doc should not propose a solution #22

Open marcoscaceres opened 9 years ago

marcoscaceres commented 9 years ago

I'm a bit bothered to see a solution proposal in the use cases document. The use cases document should really only make recommendations about what the requirements are, but not propose a solution itself. What is could do is instead point to proposed solutions - and discuss the pros and cons of those.

Wilto commented 9 years ago

Yeah; I was talking about this with @zcorpan the other day. It’s in the works.

zcorpan commented 9 years ago

http://ircbot.responsiveimages.org/bot/log/respimg/2014-11-11#T100310

marcoscaceres commented 9 years ago

I can try to be of assistance if needed.

Wilto commented 9 years ago

Absolutely, @marcoscaceres. You know we always need all the help we can get.

eeeps commented 6 years ago

@marcoscaceres ircbot.responsiveimages is down (dead?). Reading the doc, I'm not clear on which part or parts cross this line. Something here, maybe?

This document presents some of the use cases that “element queries” would solve, in allowing authors to define styles (chiefly, layouts) within an individual module on the basis of the size of the module itself rather than the viewport.

marcoscaceres commented 6 years ago

@eeeps, unfortunately, I don't manage the IRC bot :( I can't remember who does.

In any case, the OP probably stands. @yoavweiss listed a bunch of question over in #49 that the document needs to answer instead.