fileToBase64 & urlToBase64

[hemanth]

Introduction

Modern web applications frequently require conversion of file contents (such as images, videos, or documents) or URLs pointing to such resources into Base64-encoded strings. Currently, developers rely on various workarounds involving FileReader or fetch APIs to achieve this, leading to inconsistencies and complex code structures. We propose introducing a standardized window.fileToBase64 API to streamline the conversion of files and URLs to Base64, reducing developer overhead and providing a more secure, consistent, and efficient method for web applications.

---

Use Cases

1. Image Manipulation and Display: Web applications often need to convert images to Base64 strings to embed within HTML, upload to servers, or manipulate within JavaScript without relying on backend processing.
2. Offline Data Storage: For progressive web applications (PWAs) and other offline-focused applications, it’s beneficial to encode files as Base64 to store data locally for offline access, avoiding dependency on network requests.
3. Cross-Browser Consistency: Developers currently rely on varied solutions for different browsers to achieve Base64 encoding, leading to increased development time and maintenance. A standardized API would resolve these inconsistencies.
4. Simplifying User Data Processing: Applications handling user-uploaded data (such as profile pictures or document uploads) can utilize this API to streamline the client-side encoding process before sending the data securely to servers.

---

Goals

• Ease of Use: Provide a simple, standardized API for converting files and URLs to Base64 format without needing FileReader or fetch workarounds.
• Performance: Offer a fast and efficient method to encode files and URLs to Base64, optimized for use across modern web browsers.
• Security: Ensure appropriate controls and privacy considerations to prevent misuse or security vulnerabilities in handling URL-based resources.

---

Non-goals

• This proposal does not aim to provide functionality for converting Base64 back into file objects or blobs.
• This API does not handle cross-origin restrictions beyond existing CORS standards.
• The focus is on direct Base64 encoding; further data transformation (e.g., hashing or encryption) is outside this proposal’s scope.

---

Proposed Solution

We propose the introduction of window.fileToBase64 and window.urlToBase64 methods. These functions will allow developers to convert files and URLs into Base64 strings seamlessly.

Method Definitions

1. window.fileToBase64(file: File): Promise<string>

   • Accepts a File object and returns a Promise that resolves to a Base64 string of the file content.

2. window.urlToBase64(url: string): Promise<string>

   • Accepts a URL as a string and returns a Promise that resolves to the Base64 string of the resource content, adhering to CORS requirements.

Example API Usage

1. Encoding a Local File

   const fileInput = document.querySelector('#fileInput');
   fileInput.addEventListener('change', async () => {
      const file = fileInput.files[0];
      const base64String = await window.fileToBase64(file);
      console.log(base64String);
   });

2. Encoding a URL

   const imageUrl = 'https://h3manth.com/HemanthHM.webp';
   window.urlToBase64(imageUrl).then(base64String => {
      console.log(base64String);
   }).catch(error => {
      console.error("Error:", error);
   });

---

Examples

Example 1: Profile Picture Upload

A user uploads an image to set as their profile picture. Using fileToBase64, the image is encoded and then displayed inline, before uploading it as a Base64 string.

Example 2: Offline PDF Storage

An offline document viewer in a PWA fetches a document from a URL and uses urlToBase64 to store the document as Base64 in localStorage for later access.

---

Alternate Approaches

Existing solutions involve FileReader for local files and fetch for URLs. However, these approaches lack the consistency, built-in security measures, and ease of use a dedicated API could provide. Standardizing an approach on window allows consistent, optimized functionality directly within the browser context, addressing the shortcomings of ad hoc methods.

---

Privacy & Security Considerations

1. Cross-Origin Resource Sharing (CORS): The urlToBase64 method should respect CORS policies to prevent unauthorized access to restricted resources.
2. User Consent: For user-uploaded files, privacy is managed by existing user consent for file access (e.g., file input fields), and no additional risks are introduced by encoding data to Base64.
3. Memory Management: To prevent excessive memory usage, the API should limit the size of data that can be encoded to Base64, mitigating the potential for abuse in memory-constrained environments.

After careful review, no additional privacy or security concerns are expected, but community feedback is encouraged.

---

Let’s Discuss

1. API Name: Are fileToBase64 and urlToBase64 clear and suitable names?
2. Encoding Limits: Should there be an upper limit on file size for conversion to Base64, and if so, what should it be?
3. Error Handling: Should this API support specific error handling for different scenarios (e.g., invalid files, unsupported URLs)?
4. Enhancing btoa: Enhancing btoa to support file and URL encoding could indeed simplify this proposal?

[tomayac]

Are you aware of the Uint8Array to/from base64 and hex proposal?

[hemanth]

Yes @tomayac that proposal from TC39 did cross my mind.

fileToBase64 & urlToBase64 is seeking to solve file or URL to base64 without any extra steps for the API consumers.

[Gaubee]

I suggest renaming it to blobToBase64 and textToBase64