WICG / webmonetization

Proposed Web Monetization standard
https://webmonetization.org
Other
466 stars 152 forks source link

Link#load in case of disabled continous streaming, then manual tip #345

Open sublimator opened 1 year ago

sublimator commented 1 year ago

Context:

With that in mind, we tried to address the delay you mentioned specifically in
this version of the spec. The <link> load event should fire as soon as a valid
payment pointer has loaded (which is determined when JSON parsing the response,
rather than waiting for an Interledger connection), and we expect people to
unlock any extra features or content at this stage in good faith, without
waiting for the first "monetized" event (which is where the delay comes
from). 

link#load is/was intended to be used to unlock content

Where this model may break down

Automatic payment is rejected due to disabling

You don't emit the load event

State is not 'interactive' (see reference 2 re 'states')

'monetization' event may still come from user initiated tip, even though this breaks the state model, where it says no payments will come when the link is in the idle state

(I have seen examples of using only load event to unlock exclusive content)

You do emit the load event, to keep state coherent

In this case automatic payments are disabled

This means that the load event is not as useful for guessing whether payments will come, and "optimistically" show content.

Originally from: 1 / 2