search

WICG / writing-assistance-apis

A proposal for writing assistance web APIs: summarizer, writer, and rewriter
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International
17 stars 2 forks source link

The abbreviation "AI" is not timeless #9

Open nt1m opened 1 week ago

nt1m commented 1 week ago

This API references AI multiple times in the naming. I'm not sure in 5-10 years time people will still think of it as AI. AI is also an implementation detail in some way, the API should be named in a way that abstracts that away.

domenic commented 1 week ago

How do you feel about similar abbreviations in other web APIs, e.g. CSS, GPU, HTML, CSP, DOM, HTTP, SVG, RTC, ...?

nt1m commented 1 week ago

I think those which describe an end result are fine (e.g. cascading style sheets, real-time communication, content security policy, document object model, etc.).

WebGPU is a bit of a unfortunate one since it describes the means (GPU) unlike WebGL which describes the end result (Graphics Library).

AI isn't really an end result by itself, the end result is the summarizer/writer/rewriter in this case. "Writing assistant" or "writing tools" (Apple's official term for these) would be better terms in general.

nt1m commented 1 week ago

(It's possible that the AI bit gets replaced by some computer advancement in the future? who knows?)

nt1m commented 1 week ago

There's also WebNN which is an interesting case, it uses the ML namespace. I'm not too familiar with the topic but the end result does definitely look like some sort of ML low-level primitive, so ML seems OK here.

But ML would have been inappopriate if you started using ml.detectShape(), mainly because the end result is detecting a shape, not ML by itself.

domenic commented 1 week ago

Got it. We discussed related issues in https://github.com/WICG/writing-assistance-apis?tab=readme-ov-file#alternative-api-spellings ; to quote that,

We are open to such surface-level tweaks to the API entry points, and intend to gather more data from web developers on what they find more understandable and clear.