Snowball issues with cross compatibility with Thaumcraft 6

[Seiklus]

Snowballs do not contain the gelum aspect from thaumcraft 6 although they are default minecraft objects when used with this mod. This may be due to an issue with inheriting or overwriting an inheritance in thaumcraft?

How to do: Load vanilla food pantry with thaumcraft and attempt using a thaumcraft crucible with snowballs or snow. I wasn't sure if this was an issue with vanilla food or thaumcraft, so I will post in both issue logs.

[Wabbit0101]

VFP doesn't do anything with definitions or recipes for snowballs or snow and it has no explicit integration for thaumcraft. It does have recipes that use snowballs and snow...but why that would affect thaumcraft I don't know. (I confirmed also missing other stuff like oak logs, planks, etc....weird)

Don't have any suggestions for you other than perhaps try to isolate to verify it's just these two specific mods. To VFP snowballs are a minecraft object like sticks, with no significance (or changes) to that object.

[Seiklus]

I was not able to get the snowball aspects working with this even after isolating the two mods. I am using forge v 14.23.3.2655 (I have also tried the latest release) so I am now assuming it must be on the Thaumcraft side.

[Dragnier]

I can confirm this is an issue. Your mod somehow breaks Thaumcraft's Gelum aspect on Snow of all types; blocks, layers, balls. I have no clue why this is the case. Might need to get with Azanor on it somehow. I can't even try to figure out anything because I cannot see your code.

[Spiderfoxtail]

I can confirm this is an issue. Your mod somehow breaks Thaumcraft's Gelum aspect on Snow of all types; blocks, layers, balls. I have no clue why this is the case. Might need to get with Azanor on it somehow. I can't even try to figure out anything because I cannot see your code.

We are having the same issue on our server. Multiple of my players who use Thaumcraft cannot progress further because of the Gelum aspect glitch. We do not wish to remove VFP and hope this glitch can be resolved as soon as possible!

[Wabbit0101]

I'll try to look at this to see if I can detect the issue, but honestly (and I do have to code) I have no idea what this is as VFP doesn't actually do anything with snow/snowballs or any form of item substitution or tooltips. But it must be something about how VFP starts up that Thaumcraft does not like (and why just with snow?)

[Wabbit0101]

Please see update details at thaumcraft-beta/issues/1619.

@Spiderfoxtail Unfortunately because of the current limbo of Thaumcraft and my inability to workaround it (the issue isn't VFP specific and I cannot figure out exactly the recipe "shape" or ingredient context that triggers the stompage) I would say you might have to remove VFP to let your players continue. You could alternately try removing these json recipes see if that helps: homemade_butter.json and cake_sponge.json

[Spiderfoxtail]

It's okay! I rather keep VFP. We have also discovered a work around in our mod pack. We use Fire and Ice which gives Dragon ice that has the lost aspect. So we managed! Thank you for looking into this and please keep up the good work.

[bookerthegeek]

Random thought. Can you try renaming thaumcraft.jar to zthaumcraft.jar and see if that resolves the issue?

[Wabbit0101]

Nope. Did not help when I renamed Thaumcraft-1.12.2-6.1.BETA26.jar to zThaumcraft-1.12.2-6.1.BETA26.jar. Snow-related items still broken.

[sekelsta]

Thaumcraft + VFP (and no other mods, except baubles because thaumcraft needs it) makes rotten flesh give metallum instead of the usual things for some reason, also no aspects for snowballs, but Thaumcraft on its own works fine.

[The-Arcanian]

I don't have metallum on rotten flesh, but I did have the problem with gelum. I think it has to do with Thaumcraft's recursive aspect attribution from crafting. Because of VFP's crafting recipe for snowballs they and everything crafted from them lose their aspects. I was able to work around it using Mod Tweaker to add the aspects back.