search

WangYueFt / dcp

346 stars 90 forks source link

not works well given incomplete point cloud #4

Closed BlankCheng closed 5 years ago

BlankCheng commented 5 years ago

Hi, sorry to bother. When I test it with a model cloud as a souce and a transformed cloud(by random rotation and translation) as target, it works amazingly. But when I use a incomplete point cloud(a RGBD projection to 3D, incomplete here is point cloud from one perspective) as source and a complete model in the RGBD, it works poorly. I wonder it is my mistaken operation or the model itself? Will it perform as perfectly as it is on complete ones now if I train it with incomplete point cloud? Thanks! Best Cheng

zhangshabao commented 5 years ago

Excuse me, I would like to ask you how to test your own code?

WangYueFt commented 5 years ago

Hi, sorry to bother. When I test it with a model cloud as a souce and a transformed cloud(by random rotation and translation) as target, it works amazingly. But when I use a incomplete point cloud(a RGBD projection to 3D, incomplete here is point cloud from one perspective) as source and a complete model in the RGBD, it works poorly. I wonder it is my mistaken operation or the model itself? Will it perform as perfectly as it is on complete ones now if I train it with incomplete point cloud? Thanks! Best Cheng

Hi Cheng,

Yes. There is a gap between the training and testing. If you use the pretrained model, which is trained on ModelNet40, it's highly likely to fail on scans. I would suggest training on the data you collect, and then testing. We're also working on partial point cloud matching, stay tuned. :-)

Best, Yue

BlankCheng commented 5 years ago

Many thanks! I'll try it!

joy-yjl commented 4 years ago

Many thanks! I'll try it!

can you tell me how the networl perform on incomplete point cloud?