Warcraft-GoA-Development-Team / Warcraft-Guardians-of-Azeroth

"Guardians of Azeroth" is a mod with a worldwide development team, based on the Warcraft universe by Blizzard Entertainment. In this mod, our team is working to recreate the world of Azeroth in all of its glory, particularly focusing on the story of the classic Warcraft strategy games and World of Warcraft Classic.
https://www.patreon.com/thesomething
91 stars 51 forks source link

[BUG] | Horde Elections Transfer Vassals #539

Open Pinsk4111 opened 5 years ago

Pinsk4111 commented 5 years ago

DO NOT REMOVE PRE-EXISTING LINES

Mod Version:

master Branch

What expansions do you have installed:

All

Please explain your issue in as much detail as possible:

when the warchief of the horde dies the succession causes the conquered territories to the kolkars to be returned even when I built them 2 buildings to avoid nomad agitation. After the death of the leader of the horde, Orgrimmar was given someone who was not in the line of succession

Steps to reproduce the issue:

Go el's succession

Upload an attachment below: .zip of your save, or screenshots:

2 sceenshots:

antes despues

before and after

zumbak04 commented 5 years ago

when the warchief of the horde dies the succession causes the conquered territories to the kolkars to be returned even when I built them 2 buildings to avoid nomad agitation.

Buildings or holdings? Since now the Horde is feudal, you should build holdings (castle, city).

After the death of the leader of the horde, Orgrimmar was given someone who was not in the line of succession

Who? Dynasty heir inherits counties. They're not elective.

Pinsk4111 commented 5 years ago

Hi zumbak04. The game was a multiplayer, the leader of the horde was king of orgrimmar, with the kings of azhara, barrens and mulgore as vassals as can be seen in the images. After the leader died, there were successions in his vassals although they had not died, it can be seen how Barrens suffered a succession in Nittamosew. The King of Barrens possessed as vassals all the counts of southern Orgrimmar, after Go El died, the king of Barrens lost these vassals and passed to the successor of the kingdom of Orgrimmar (I do not explain why the King of Barrens has successions if not died) The Kingdom of Orgrimmar was elective and despite having chosen a successor, the northern territories of orgrimmar were ceded to another character. I attach a save before and after the succession so you can experience it.

saves.zip

Galvador1 commented 5 years ago

i'm suspecting that since the e_horde is elective and k_durotar is elective too and they choose different heir. since the e_horde chooses non dynastic heir, the logic was the whole titles (county and duchies) goes agnatic-cognatic primogeniture first which in this case is eldest living grandson of eldest son, Mouda. then since you choose the heir of k_durotar someone else, he only got k_durotar and usurping one random county. Well it's hardcoded iirc so kinda a bad luck.

zumbak04 commented 5 years ago

@Pinsk4111, yep, @Galvador1 is right.

Click to expand ![image](https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/46384992/61956863-0a745d00-afcf-11e9-8689-f81e986e13d8.png) ![image](https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/46384992/61956871-0ea07a80-afcf-11e9-89b5-9226888974f8.png)

One of Go'el's sons inherits lands.

After the leader died, there were successions in his vassals although they had not died, it can be seen how Barrens suffered a succession in Nittamosew.

There was Nomad Agitation.

The King of Barrens possessed as vassals all the counts of southern Orgrimmar, after Go El died, the king of Barrens lost these vassals and passed to the successor of the kingdom of Orgrimmar (I do not explain why the King of Barrens has successions if not died)

Hmm, ye, see. That's interesting, going to check how it works in vanilla.

Pinsk4111 commented 5 years ago

Thanks for your answers, I take this opportunity to tell you that your mod is very good and we play it with friends often. We will continue playing and informing if we find more bugs.

zumbak04 commented 5 years ago

Thanks! Still testing to understand what happened with vassals. So the issue isn't closed yet.

zumbak04 commented 5 years ago

Tested it in vanilla and don't even know... is it bug or feature...

Click to expand ![image](https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/46384992/61973503-36a2d480-aff5-11e9-8f8b-cef6a932328f.png) ![image](https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/46384992/61974011-8afa8400-aff6-11e9-8cb7-a581652ad1c7.png)

If kingdom titles are not the de-jure vassal of a certain empire title, the game transfers vassals according to the de-jure borders of said kingdoms if they are held by the preceding emperor. Tested it with the Wenedish Empire and Italy and Romagna kingdom titles.