WasmEdge / docs

https://wasmedge.org/docs/
Apache License 2.0
16 stars 55 forks source link

Video removed from docs pages #208

Closed kelvinparmar closed 5 months ago

kelvinparmar commented 5 months ago

Explanation

Related issue

What type of PR is this

Proposed Changes

alabulei1 commented 5 months ago

Hello, I am a code review bot on flows.network. Here are my reviews of code commits in this PR.


In summary, from reviewing all the provided summaries, the potential issues and errors in the pull request are as follows:

  1. Lack of context: In several patches, it is unclear why certain changes were made and what the purpose or reasoning behind them is. It would be helpful to have more explanation in the commit messages or pull request description to provide the necessary context.

  2. Missing justification: In some cases, video links were changed or removed without any explanation or justification. It is important to provide a clear reason for such changes to understand their necessity.

  3. Privacy concern: In one patch, an email address was exposed. This should be removed or masked for privacy reasons.

  4. Maintainability: In one patch, the video URLs were hard-coded, which may not be the best practice for maintaining the links in the future.

  5. Coherence and completeness of documentation: Removing videos or sections from the documentation may impact its coherence and completeness. It is important to ensure that necessary updates or adjustments are made to maintain the overall quality of the documentation.

The most important findings from these summaries are:

Overall, there are areas for improvement in terms of providing context, explanation, and justification for changes, as well as ensuring privacy and maintaining the quality of the documentation.

Details

Commit ab2f3bf00677b8d139a4e1a603508478fb8ab40e

Key changes:

Potential problems:

Overall, the patch seems to add new content to the "talks" page, but more context and justification for these changes are needed.

Commit 5cd2fe56f92d79a97585b31d02579dd19a6bedcf

Key changes in the patch:

  1. The video link for the talk "Optimizing Microservices with WebAssembly and Linux Containers: Exploring Hybrid Container Architectures" on December 6th is changed to a new URL.
  2. The video link for the talk "Lightweight and High-Performance Microservices with Dapr and WasmEdge" on December 5th is changed to a new URL.
  3. The video link for the talk "Efficient and Cross-Platform AI Inference Apps Using Rust and Wasm" on December 5th is changed to a new URL.

Potential problems:

  1. The patch does not provide any justification or explanation for why the video links were changed. It would be helpful to have a commit message explaining the reason for these changes.
  2. It is unclear if the new video URLs are valid or if they point to the correct videos.
  3. There are no other changes mentioned in the patch. It would be helpful to include a brief summary of other changes made in this patch or provide additional patches if there are more changes.

Commit 4a430ca7c59904a4cbe689ed068120849b56bafa

Key changes:

Potential problems:

Overall, the removal of the videos should be justified and communicated properly to the team and users. It would be advisable to provide a reason for the removal or discuss the change with the relevant stakeholders.

Commit b8c537d40a23f535341838215ae1384ee6c3ee0f

Key changes:

Potential problems:

Commit 1f34d69d4d87ae56e184bc77f9cd494e155a4b17

Key changes:

Potential problems:

Overall, the key change in this patch is the removal of the video link, but without further information, it is difficult to assess the reasons behind it.

Commit 6c7110bc8242ed1c455dc9186731757e96b3eda6

The key changes in this patch are as follows:

  1. Added a new FAQ page with frequently asked questions about WasmEdge.
  2. Added a new style guide page for new contributors.
  3. Moved the troubleshooting guide to the new location.

Potential problems or areas of improvement:

  1. The patch introduces several new files, so it would be helpful to include a brief description in the PR or commit message explaining the purpose of these new files.
  2. It would be beneficial to add a link to the FAQ page in the overview page to make it easier for users to access it.
  3. The style guide page could benefit from more detailed guidelines and examples.
  4. It would be useful to have a separate section in the style guide for documentation style guidelines, as it currently covers both documentation and coding style.
  5. There could be potential issues with code formatting and consistency, as it is not clear from the patch if there were any changes to the codebase itself.

Overall, the changes seem reasonable, but it would be helpful to have more context and information about the purpose and scope of these changes.

Commit 5888c32a7f2dc9a7d28c05aaf863da03c8e68254

Key changes:

Potential problems:

  1. It's unclear what type of changes are being made without more context.
  2. The email address is exposed in the patch. The address should be removed or masked for privacy reasons.
  3. The video URLs are hard-coded in the patch, which may not be ideal for maintaining the links in the future.

Overall, this patch seems to add videos for various talks to the "talks.md" file. However, it lacks context, and there are a few potential issues with privacy and maintainability of the video URLs.

Commit 7e4b0e110643e87c4aa7e49d037260d4af39a09e

Key changes in this patch include:

  1. The video URLs in the talks.md file have been updated to different YouTube video links.
  2. The date for one of the talks has been changed from December 5th to December 6th.

Potential problems with this patch:

  1. The video URLs have been replaced with different YouTube links. It is unclear if the previous videos have been removed or if they were replaced intentionally with new videos. The reasons for these changes should be clarified in the patch description or in a comment.
  2. The date change for one of the talks may require additional updates in other parts of the code or documentation. It is important to ensure that all references to the date are consistent across the project.

Commit 74fd60e998816ab1bbcc317c1cb7fe58b2e0c6d8

Key Changes:

Potential Problems:

Overall, the key change in this patch is the removal of video URLs and descriptions from the talks.md file. It is important to address the potential problems mentioned above and communicate with the submitter to gather further information if necessary.

Commit 2f88630d826219b47a0fe66e38d339c770a2754f

Key changes:

Potential problems:

Commit 4ba2c83ef6dd9e270a5229ec714410dad6a6a0c3

Key changes:

Potential problems:

Other observations: