search

WerewolvesRevamped / Werewolves-Roles

The role book for Werewolves Revamped
7 stars 8 forks source link

Multiple Fortune Apprentices #1205

Closed CrowdfordBot closed 11 months ago

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

shapechange: The Fortune Apprentice description doesn't technically specify what happens if there are multiple FAs, but it's pretty obviously phrased so that if there were multiple, they would all assume the role of the first dead/changed TI at the same time. This seems intentional, but is it something that we want? It would seem more balanced to have only one (selected arbitrarily) assume the role, until the next TI death/rolechange.

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

captainluffy: I think that's how we usually do it for promotion roles

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

captainluffy: Like I think it holds true for everything

CrowdfordBot commented 1 year ago

shapechange: yeah it definitely has precedent, but i just wonder if it should be this way for FA specifically

CrowdfordBot commented 12 months ago

mctsts: I feel like either option we dont want for FA

CrowdfordBot commented 12 months ago

mctsts: Giving town 2 backups for one TI just always seems bad I think?

CrowdfordBot commented 12 months ago

mctsts: It's weird if their FT dies and they get 2 new FTs

CrowdfordBot commented 12 months ago

mctsts: but it's also weird if their FT dies, and they get a new one and then the new one dies and they get yet another one

CrowdfordBot commented 12 months ago

shapechange:

It's weird if their FT dies and they get 2 new FTs

i think this is definitely worse than the other option

CrowdfordBot commented 12 months ago

mctsts: It probably is

CrowdfordBot commented 12 months ago

shapechange:

but it's also weird if their FT dies, and they get a new one and then the new one dies and they get yet another one

this is obviously objectionable, but i can only image having 2 FA in a large game with several TI, so it would be more likely for them to imitate different TI

CrowdfordBot commented 12 months ago

mctsts: I guess it could work

CrowdfordBot commented 12 months ago

mctsts: It can probably be added

CrowdfordBot commented 12 months ago

mctsts: I do kinda dislike making role descs longer for unlikely edge cases

CrowdfordBot commented 12 months ago

shapechange: it'd only be a line

CrowdfordBot commented 12 months ago

shapechange:

If there are several Fortune Apprentices when the role would be assumed, a random Fortune Apprentice is selected to assume the role.. The rest remain Fortune Apprentices.

CrowdfordBot commented 12 months ago

mctsts: That's three lines

CrowdfordBot commented 12 months ago

mctsts: But it's fine

CrowdfordBot commented 12 months ago

mctsts: We can take out This will not happen if the Fortune Apprentice’s role has changed.

CrowdfordBot commented 12 months ago

shapechange: yes

CrowdfordBot commented 12 months ago

shapechange: i thought id taken that out myself lol but i mustve forgotten

CrowdfordBot commented 11 months ago

captainluffy: is it already taken out or still needs ot be done?

CrowdfordBot commented 11 months ago

mctsts: both the addition and the removal have not be done i think

CrowdfordBot commented 11 months ago

venomousbirds: seems unanimous, just needs PR

CrowdfordBot commented 11 months ago

captainluffy: <@&1045732542399131769> Fortune Apprentice update

  1. if multiple FA, all change (current version)
  2. if multiple FA, only 1 changes
CrowdfordBot commented 11 months ago

captainluffy: imo 2 is better but adds a lot of text for something that very unlikely to happen anyways

CrowdfordBot commented 11 months ago

shapechange: "a lot of text" two entire sentences

CrowdfordBot commented 11 months ago

captainluffy: https://github.com/McTsts/Werewolves-Roles/pull/1270