Whisky-App / Whisky

A modern Wine wrapper for macOS built with SwiftUI
https://getwhisky.app
GNU General Public License v3.0
11.85k stars 252 forks source link

[Feature]: Update Wine to 9.2 #841

Open bolandnick18 opened 6 months ago

bolandnick18 commented 6 months ago

Is your feature request related to a problem?

I am not sure why this app is using the outdated version of wine 7 and I am wonder if you can please update to wine 9.2. its has address some of the issues compared to wine 7.x

here more info:

https://gitlab.winehq.org/wine/wine/-/releases/wine-9.2

Describe the solution you'd like

Please update wine 9.2

Anything else?

no more comments

Issue Language

JSP100 commented 6 months ago

Well, my guess is that Apple uses Wine 7.x to build their Game Porting Toolkit, so as Whisky. (is that the case?)

blackxfiied commented 6 months ago

@JSP100 yeah so it's not really as simple as just updating

Mateus109 commented 6 months ago

Didn't the Whisky devs say they wouldn't support Wine 8 or 9 because that would take business away from Crossover? If you what Wine 8+, buy Crossover. Think of Whisky as a free version of Crossover, with limited features. Actually, now that Crossover is officially on Wine 9, maybe the Whisky devs will update to Wine 8.

bolandnick18 commented 6 months ago

crossover software is two pricing for me

bmx666 commented 6 months ago

Didn't the Whisky devs say they wouldn't support Wine 8 or 9 because that would take business away from Crossover? If you what Wine 8+, buy Crossover. Think of Whisky as a free version of Crossover, with limited features. Actually, now that Crossover is officially on Wine 9, maybe the Whisky devs will update to Wine 8.

wine 7 is no longer supported by winetricks:

warning: Your version of wine 7.7 is no longer supported upstream. You should upgrade to 8.x

blackxfiied commented 6 months ago

Didn't the Whisky devs say they wouldn't support Wine 8 or 9 because that would take business away from Crossover? If you what Wine 8+, buy Crossover. Think of Whisky as a free version of Crossover, with limited features. Actually, now that Crossover is officially on Wine 9, maybe the Whisky devs will update to Wine 8.

exactly why it's still on wine 7

if you're on the discord server, here's the announcement https://discord.com/channels/1115955071549702235/1116876782994468985/1151994321860567141

d9j commented 6 months ago

this project policy is non compete agreement with crosssover. wellcome to fork the project and update wine dependency . i personally tried to upgrade wine by compelling wine from source. however i had no success launching games due to unclear crashing errors.

IsaacMarovitz commented 6 months ago

It is not enough to simply use Wine from source. CrossOver works because they have many in-house fixes that allow applications like Steam to work out of the box. Unless we develop those kinds of fixes ourselves, updating to Wine 9 would probably break more than it would fix.

100tomer commented 1 week ago

So we should expect to always stay on wine 7.7?