search

WhiteHouse / petitions

Drupal installation profile powering We The People at petitions.whitehouse.gov
https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/
1.14k stars 336 forks source link

Why the software history was not kept? #108

Open gustavopinto opened 8 years ago

gustavopinto commented 8 years ago

Hi there,

I'm a researcher studying software evolution. As part of my current research, I'm studying the implications of open-sourcing a proprietary software, for instance, if the project succeed in attracting newcomers. However, I observed that some projects, like petitions, deleted their software history when transitioning to open-source.

https://github.com/WhiteHouse/petitions/commit/5733575c4fe85c9f8ea0a7db9fa38d3f2d339fc0

Knowing that software history is indispensable for developers (e.g., developers need to refer to history several times a day), I would like to ask petitions developers the following four brief questions:

  1. Why did you decide to not keep the software history?
  2. Do the core developers faced any kind of problems, when trying to refer to the old history? If so, how did they solve these problems?
  3. Do the newcomers faced any kind of problems, when trying to refer to the old history? If so, how did they solve these problems?
  4. How does the lack of history impacted on software evolution? Does it placed any burden in understanding and evolving the software?

Thanks in advance for your collaboration,

Gustavo Pinto, PhD http://www.gustavopinto.org

gustavopinto commented 8 years ago

hi @TravisCarden, do you have any comments?

TravisCarden commented 8 years ago

Hello, @gustavopinto. The commit you refer to was made long before I had any relationship to the project. I'm not qualified to comment on the decisions of those who preceded me, and as I'm no longer active, I'm not personally authorized to answer your other questions. Sorry!