WhyAsh5114 / MyFit

Workout tracker inspired by the RP Hypertrophy App
https://my-fit-whyash5114.vercel.app/
GNU Affero General Public License v3.0
26 stars 3 forks source link

Muscle list #37

Closed Propanotrio1 closed 1 month ago

Propanotrio1 commented 1 month ago

First of all, great job you are doing here. I hope I can help with suggestions.

Y created a mesocycle and I started listing exercices and what I observe is the need of some additional muscles in the list:

Keep it up!!

asherrrrrrrrrrr commented 1 month ago

and neck please!

WhyAsh5114 commented 1 month ago

Hey guys, thanks for the suggestions, but I need a bit more clarity in this, the neck can be added easily as it's a completely different muscle group. Even adductors and abductors are actually separate from the quads anatomically. But here's the issue:

Some muscles are commonly trained with other major muscle groups

Muscles like the soleus are always trained in standing variations of the calf raises, they can be specifically targeted slightly more in seated variations but it doesn't increase their activation as much AFAIK.

Another example for this is rhomboids, which are commonly trained during rows, which most people consider as a upper back or rather trap-dominant exercise. If we separate the muscles as much as we can for the sake of accuracy, it makes it a bit confusing for beginners and even for us who know anatomy well enough as what we should select for an exercise which targets multiple muscle groups.

I am still open to feedback in this part.

If we separate major muscle groups, we need to do it for all groups

Even if we do separate the calves muscle group into the gastrocnemius and soleus, we need to do so for others as well: like the chest being split up into upper and middle, the triceps being split into either all the 3 heads, or the (lateral+medial) head and long head according to the function. It makes the list a bit inconsistent.

There are a few options to fix them though, one is where we have multiple lists with different levels of detail, like a general one which we use now, and a more sophisticated one with as much separation as possible, its a great idea for sure, but we need to make this a bit more consistent so users don't get confused. Would appreciate any ideas you guys have in mind :)

Propanotrio1 commented 1 month ago

I agree with all what you said. The thing is that you are forced to chose a muscle, and for abductors and adductors I put them with hamstring exercises.

Indeed, too much resolution is not needed, and a list of main muscles is enough :)

WhyAsh5114 commented 1 month ago

so we should keep it as is? (along with neck)

asherrrrrrrrrrr commented 1 month ago

I agree. I put abductors with glutes and adductors with quads. Maybe you could add an option for a custom muscle for those who care to be specific although not nessary.

asherrrrrrrrrrr commented 1 month ago

so we should keep it as is? (along with neck)

I'd appreciate if you can add neck please

WhyAsh5114 commented 1 month ago

so we should keep it as is? (along with neck)

I'd appreciate if you can add neck please

done, added neck muscle group!

Propanotrio1 commented 1 month ago

_

Maybe you could add an option for a custom muscle for those who care to be specific although not nessary

_

It is a good option, without adding too much resolution for new users or beginners.

WhyAsh5114 commented 1 month ago

It is a good option, without adding too much resolution for new users or beginners.

Got it, I'll add the custom one in v3 of the app, if you want I could add adductors and abductors right now in v2 as they are actually different from the quadriceps and can be specifically targeted which might make sense for some users. Do let me know if you want it.

Propanotrio1 commented 1 month ago

If it doesn't take you that much time, It would be grateful 💯 I will start using the app tomorrow at the gym (replacing my old Excel), really excited

WhyAsh5114 commented 1 month ago

Done! Hey, even I used to use Excel for my workouts, part of my motivation for this app was to get away from Excel 😁. Good luck with your sessions!

asherrrrrrrrrrr commented 1 month ago

so we should keep it as is? (along with neck)

I'd appreciate if you can add neck please

done, added neck muscle group!

Great thank you!