Wimmics / solid-start

Projet SOLID Inria - Startin'blox
MIT License
1 stars 0 forks source link

range of idx:hasTarget and idx:hasSubIndex are wrong #42

Closed pchampin closed 6 days ago

pchampin commented 1 week ago

the current ontology says:

idx:hasTarget   rdfs:hasRange xsd:anyUri .
idx:hasSubIndex rdfs:hasRange xsd:anyUri .

This is incorrect. It means that the values of these properties should be literals with the datatype »sd:anyUri. And semantically, it would mean that the target / subindex is the URI itself, rather than the resource identified by that URI.

pchampin commented 1 week ago

The correct range for idx:hasSubIndex should obviously be idx:Index.

pchampin commented 1 week ago

For the range of idx:hasTarget, I see several options:

My preference would be to go for option two (unspecified) for the moment, and in parallel we create an erratum for the RDF WG, suggesting that the rdf: namespace should contain an IRI for the concept of RDF Source, and we eventually use this one.

lecoqlibre commented 1 week ago

Done both. Used option 2 regarding idx:hasTarget. Waiting for the erratum.

pchampin commented 6 days ago

Waiting for the erratum.

In fact I raised an issue instead.