Open Winniehyx opened 3 years ago
The error message while not extremely detailed, it already indicates that the email should be in proper format, missing a username should be obvious error for the user
Team chose [response.Rejected
]
Reason for disagreement: Error messages are supposed to be detailed. It does indicate that the email should be in proper format but users might not know what constitutes a "proper format". You cannot simple assume that users would type the correct thing. In addition, a case whereby the user does not want to put the local part of the email(not username by the way) would be that they do not want to give up the details for their email. An appropriate error message would include local-part should not be empty. In fact, I down-played the severity and I personally feel that severity would be medium as the error message is not elaborate enough.
Team chose [type.DocumentationBug
]
Originally [type.FeatureFlaw
]
Reason for disagreement: This is a feature flaw. Documentation bug refers to those written.
add n/John Wayne p/88765432 e/@example.com a/John street, block123, #01-01 b/1998 07 10