Addison-Stavlo
commented
4 years ago Post Content I feel the needs of this block are very similar to that of the Template Part. So whatever fits the needs of the template part should ideally fit the needs of the post content (whether persistent block navigator and breadcrumb names are sufficient on their own, or we need to add other indicators like borders, labels, scrims, spotlights, etc., my feeling is that these two blocks will require the same sort of indications).
Template areas may be a bit different though, as the two entity blocks mentioned above are children of the Template. So if there is a need for visual indications (beyond block navigator and breadcrumb names), those visual indicators will definitely be a bit different. Perhaps, if we do something like apply a very light border around template part and post content when working within them then a solution for the Template area could be to triggers those light borders to appear for all the Template Parts/Post Contents on the page when working within the template area. This kind of thing might make it more clear where you are working on the page.
That said:
It's important to call out that the editing experience may improve when Shaun's changes to the topbar are implemented (#25085) alongside a persistent block navigator (#22113). As a result, this issue is acting as more of a placeholder to ensure that, when template part visiblity is improved, the template area and post content block editing experience are addressed as well.
It does sound like a good idea to assess this after we see where our weak points are after the above is implemented.
annezazu
Note: When we say "template" in template visibility, we mean the part of the site editor template that doesn't belong to another entity. In other words, it's the area between our template parts and post content.
Is your feature request related to a problem? Please describe. Related to this issue and this comment.
It's difficult to discern where the post content block and template begins and ends in the site editor. It also seems unintuitive to navigate seamlessly between template parts, the template area, and post content in the site editor.
It's important to call out that the editing experience may improve when Shaun's changes to the topbar are implemented (#25085) alongside a persistent block navigator (https://github.com/WordPress/gutenberg/issues/22113). As a result, this issue is acting as more of a placeholder to ensure that, when template part visiblity is improved, the template area and post content block editing experience are addressed as well.