WordPress / wporg-showcase-2022

The official theme of the WordPress.org showcase.
https://wordpress.org/showcase/
19 stars 4 forks source link

Consider merging "Flavors" with "Tags" #230

Open ndiego opened 9 months ago

ndiego commented 9 months ago

Flavors were implemented in Showcase v2 to keep the functionality consistent with the current Showcase. After using the v2 site, the third taxonomy feels burdensome as a user. There are too many things to search by, and it is unclear what "Flavor" means.

Homepage Single Site
image image

Therefore, I propose that we convert the existing Flavors into tags. We can ignore "WordPress.org", so only "WordPress Multisite" and "WordPress VIP" would be added as tags. Then:

I don't think we should remove the Flavor taxonomy entirely at the moment, just remove the visual presence on the front end. There may be a use case in the future. But for now, tags and categories suffice.

cc @marko-srb @jasmussen @eidolonnight

jasmussen commented 9 months ago

No strong opinion on my part.

ndiego commented 9 months ago

@marko-srb @fcoveram any thoughts on this one? If you both are comfortable moving forward, I can get this in motion. Thanks!

renintw commented 8 months ago

I'll remove flavors from these places:

1. Homepage Filter. Search Page Filter. Archive Page Filter👇

image

2. Browse (copy would change to Browse by category or tag, thoughts on this?) 👇

image

3. Single Page 👇

image
ndiego commented 8 months ago

After further discussion, let's put this enhancement on hold. Sorry for the extra work here! For now, we will keep feature parity with the current Showcase (which includes Flavors), and then we will reassess in the future.

marko-srb commented 8 months ago

I think its ok to hide the Flavors, but also think this could wait to post-launch.