Working-Title-MSFS-Mods / fspackages

Working Title FS Packages
MIT License
1.15k stars 109 forks source link

[CJ4] Frequency Data FMC page issues with long localizer descriptions #1158

Open gr33nwich opened 3 years ago

gr33nwich commented 3 years ago

Using the CJ4 (0.12.1) with the latest Navigraph NAVDATA (AIRAC 2104) installed results in display issues on the FREQUENCY DATA page on the FMC. The screenshot below shows the Frequency page for the EDDF airport:

CJ4_FrequencyData

If the set of displayed frequencies contains localizer frequencies, long descriptors such as ILS/GS CAT III RW25C will overlap the shorter COM frequency descriptions such as GROUND or ATIS, resulting into something unreadable like ATILS/GS CAT III RW25C.

I'm not sure of how the real life FMC would handle this or if Navigraph are not respecting a maximum description length for the localizer freqs, but possibly there's a way to handle the descriptions in a more readable way.

dga711 commented 3 years ago

Hi. Yeah we don't really know how real world data would label those. We just use what comes from data and it is that long sadly. So you have to guess quite a bit.

gr33nwich commented 3 years ago

Given that the real life parsing method is unknown, how about the following enhancement then: Whenever a frequency descriptor contains a string such as CAT I or CAT II+III (different combinations will need to be detected), just omit it when parsing the string for the FMC page.

Staying with my initial example of Frankfurt/Main (EDDF), both the ILS OR LOC RWY 25C and the CAT II/III ILS RWY 25C NAVDATA are sharing the same localizer (IFCW) with the exact same frequency (111.55)

--> For the FREQUENCY DATA FMC page, the ILS category is irrelevant and can be omitted to save display space. The key difference for the pilot are the different decision altitudes associated with CAT I and CAT II/III, resulting in different minimums settings in the PFD.

K20017 commented 3 years ago

Yes, the categories would be omitted in the real thing, would just be "ILS + letter if applicable + runway. "

gr33nwich commented 3 years ago

Is there any chance to support you implementing this?

mattnischan commented 3 years ago

I'm not sure I follow what you mean by support, @gr33nwich.