WorldHistoricalGazetteer / whg3

Version 3 beta
BSD 3-Clause "New" or "Revised" License
4 stars 4 forks source link

Portal title conforming to search term and/or title of chosen search result #251

Open kgeographer opened 3 months ago

kgeographer commented 3 months ago

It has always seemed a drawback that when for example I search for 'Abydos', the top hit is titled Çanakkale, and the portal title reads "Dardanelles; Çanakkale; Abydos; Hellespont; ..."

A tricky thing to implement, but would improve UX no doubt.

docuracy commented 3 months ago

@kgeographer : Am I to understand that you'd like this highlighted text to be replaced with the searched-for "Abydos"? But what if I'd done a similar-to search on "abydds", which of the variants should be used to form the title? And what about all the other results which also contain "Abydos" or something similar among their variants? It's a bit of a hornet's nest, I think, and likely to introduce confusion, whereas the current behaviour is at least consistent.

Image

docuracy commented 3 months ago

Other options, none of which I think are any good:

kgeographer commented 2 months ago

Ok, talked me out of it. It was an idea hatched long ago, before the advent of similar queries On Jul 8, 2024, at 23:15, Stephen Gadd @.***> wrote: @kgeographer : Am I to understand that you'd like this highlighted text to be replaced with the searched-for "Abydos"? But what if I'd done a similar-to search on "abydds", which of the variants should be used to form the title? And what about all the other results which also contain "Abydos" or something similar among their variants? It's a bit of a hornet's nest, I think, and likely to introduce confusion, whereas the current behaviour is at least consistent. image.png (view on web)

—Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or unsubscribe.You are receiving this because you were mentioned.Message ID: @.***>