WrappedBTC / bitcoin-token-smart-contracts

MIT License
132 stars 91 forks source link

WBTC sent to WBTC address #50

Closed rggithubether closed 10 months ago

rggithubether commented 1 year ago

Hello, PLEASE HELP! I've made a mistake transferring my WBTC from coinbase exchange to Coinbase wallet. Instead of sending to my wallet ERC20 address, I've sent to the same WBTC contract address. heres the txn for ur reference,

https://etherscan.io/tx/0x98f6e568a3cae28a1f9bd205c8ca2b994ddb702e94b72fa590b62367d3ad7033

it's not a lot of money but > $700 is a lot for me. I got this github link from https://twitter.com/mosayeri. if u need further info i can be reached at https://twitter.com/rgcoin1126.

Thank u so much in advance.

rggithubether commented 1 year ago

hello? can anyone please help me on this?

rggithubether commented 1 year ago

@yaronvel would u be able to assist me?

ravz commented 1 year ago

good luck, I've been trying for 2 years!

rggithubether commented 1 year ago

@ravz any DAO people reached out to u?

rggithubether commented 1 year ago

Hello WBTC DAO,

This is the txn hash for this issue.

https://etherscan.io/tx/0x1f1c8971dec959d38bcaa5606eb474d028617752240727692cd5ef21a435d847?fbclid=IwAR0W3fBY8HmJEJBuG_pWHkGQ1HyMYb18uph9WkwQbzgw9S9j-bZ07Y3tTAo

As stated earlier, I was trying to move my WBTC from Coinbase Central Exchange to Coinbase Wallet. Instead of using my wallet's ERC20 address, I accidentally copied the same WBTC contract address.

I will reach out to Coinbase Support to check if its possible to get a verifiable process to move back my WBTC to its origin.

Thank you.

rggithubether commented 1 year ago

Hello WBTC DAO,

Here's the response I got from Coinbase Support.

"I totally understand the confusion this has caused you but the only support team who can help you retrieve the funds is the receiving platform of your transactions. Coinbase don't have the instructions on how to do that since the transaction was not in Coinbase anymore.

Now, regarding your question, the only team who can answer that is the WBTC Dao platform. You can ask help from them since they have your transactions and not us, "

rggithubether commented 1 year ago

additional response from Coinbase Support,

"What I'm saying is, they're the one who can best help you retrieve the funds and not us, Coinbase. So, I highly suggest to ask for their full cooperation and instructions on how to do that.

Also, I can't provide you the information that you are asking for security purposes."

ravz commented 1 year ago

@rggithubether Coinbase won't be able to assist you, only the WBTC team. We're trying to push for this PR to be processed https://github.com/WrappedBTC/DAO/pull/12 which will allow them the ability to reverse those transactions.

rggithubether commented 1 year ago

thank u @ravz

joekoh-bg commented 1 year ago

@rggithubether right now we are only able to send back to the address that the tokens were transferred from. Since this particular transaction originated from a CEX address, we will need to coordinate with Coinbase on how to get this returned back to them, so they can move it back to your wallet. Have you reached out to them? What have they said?

rggithubether commented 1 year ago

hi @joekoh-bg yes many times. this is what i got from coinbase. so helpless with the situation...would it be possible to return my WBTC to my DEX wallet since sending it back to CEX is a very difficult situation? i got the txn hash and receipts...

cb-wbtc-issue-1 cb-wbtc-issue-2 cb-wbtc-issue-3

ravz commented 1 year ago

@rggithubether you need to ask Coinbase if they will credit your account balance if the transaction is returned to their internal wallet

ravz commented 1 year ago

hi @joekoh-bg is there any ETA on when these return transactions will execute? Has been 18 months since I sent.

rggithubether commented 1 year ago

hi @joekoh-bg @ravz i reached out again to CB today, and here's the response that i got (see below). really need this WBTC back to me please. im on a dead end with Coinbase CEX here, is it possible to airdrop to my Coinbase DEX wallet?

this is the receipt, https://etherscan.io/tx/0x1f1c8971dec959d38bcaa5606eb474d028617752240727692cd5ef21a435d847?fbclid=IwAR0W3fBY8HmJEJBuG_pWHkGQ1HyMYb18uph9WkwQbzgw9S9j-bZ07Y3tTAo

wbtc-cb-issue-7 wbtc-cb-issue-8 wbtc-cb-issue-9

rggithubether commented 1 year ago

hello @joekoh-bg kindly advise thank u

rggithubether commented 1 year ago

hello @joekoh-bg any update please? thank u

khademreza688 commented 1 year ago
rggithubether commented 1 year ago

@joekoh-bg hi just touching base if u have any update on this? Thank u

rggithubether commented 1 year ago

Hi @joekoh-bg please advise any update on this

rggithubether commented 1 year ago

@joekoh-bg any update on this please?

joekoh-bg commented 1 year ago

@rggithubether do you have a Telegram handle?

Smotheredhope80 commented 1 year ago

I am in the same situation except, that I was trying to withdraw USDC from Coinbase into my Arbitrium wallet so I could buy some WBTC but I accidently sent it to the WBTC contract address on Arbitrium. It sucks cause I know that it will be a 2 step process if funds do get reverted. Contract send back to owner (Coinbase) then I have to convince Coinbase that it was me that the funds need to go to.

TX Hash 0xc0e75d75c6dba7062cea3e673c90fb4a602dcb039cd1e9f6cdbb2e42764dbb0c

https://arbiscan.io/tx/0xc0e75d75c6dba7062cea3e673c90fb4a602dcb039cd1e9f6cdbb2e42764dbb0c

ravz commented 1 year ago

@Smotheredhope80 good luck myself and others have been waiting 2.5 years for DAO to approve a single transaction

rggithubether commented 1 year ago

@rggithubether do you have a Telegram handle?

@joekoh-bg no I don't have any telegram handle

rggithubether commented 1 year ago

@tranvictor @joekoh-bg any update please?

joekoh-bg commented 1 year ago

@rggithubether I have emailed Coinbase support seeing if they will help verify your's (and other folks') account identities and also provide us with an address for where we can return WBTC to.

Smotheredhope80 commented 1 year ago

Thank you for the update @joekoh-bg and all of your work on this. Do you know if this is just for the WBTC contract on the Ethereum Network or is the Arbitrum WBTC contract (0x2f2a2543B76A4166549F7aaB2e75Bef0aefC5B0f) also being cleared of accidental token sends?

rggithubether commented 1 year ago

@rggithubether I have emailed Coinbase support seeing if they will help verify your's (and other folks') account identities and also provide us with an address for where we can return WBTC to.

@joekoh-bg I really appreciate you. Thank you for the update!

rggithubether commented 1 year ago

@rggithubether I have emailed Coinbase support seeing if they will help verify your's (and other folks') account identities and also provide us with an address for where we can return WBTC to.

@joekoh-bg I really appreciate you. Thank you for the update!

Hi @joekoh-bg pls advise if u heard back from CB? Thank u.

rggithubether commented 1 year ago

@joekoh-bg any news? thanks in advance.

rggithubether commented 1 year ago

@joekoh-bg @tranvictor any update guys? please advise.

joekoh-bg commented 1 year ago

Still trying to get through. Their chat & email was a dead end. Hoping social media & employee contact bears more fruit.

rggithubether commented 1 year ago

Still trying to get through. Their chat & email was a dead end. Hoping social media & employee contact bears more fruit.

I've tried reaching out to them, they used proxy chains and won't share any other info on this. Is there any other options to return my WBTC? this is almost a year now.

joekoh-bg commented 1 year ago

Give me a few days to finish my conversations with them through these new avenues and I will report back.

rggithubether commented 1 year ago

Give me a few days to finish my conversations with them through these new avenues and I will report back.

thank you so much

joekoh-bg commented 1 year ago

@rggithubether Coinbase has reached out asking for proof of transactions. I sent them this hash: https://etherscan.io/tx/0x1f1c8971dec959d38bcaa5606eb474d028617752240727692cd5ef21a435d847

and am awaiting reply for them to confirm where the DAO should send back to.

rggithubether commented 1 year ago

@rggithubether Coinbase has reached out asking for proof of transactions. I sent them this hash: https://etherscan.io/tx/0x1f1c8971dec959d38bcaa5606eb474d028617752240727692cd5ef21a435d847

and am awaiting reply for them to confirm where the DAO should send back to.

thank you for the update @joekoh-bg the hash is correct, https://etherscan.io/tx/0x1f1c8971dec959d38bcaa5606eb474d028617752240727692cd5ef21a435d847

this is also proof of receipt from my mobile (coinbase apps). WBTC-transaction-11-19-2022

joekoh-bg commented 1 year ago

@rggithubether great news! Coinbase has agreed to help returning the WBTC in this transaction: https://etherscan.io/tx/0x1f1c8971dec959d38bcaa5606eb474d028617752240727692cd5ef21a435d847

The DAO has not yet started to reconcile any refunds for CEX sends, so please be patient with us. We are currently in the midst of returning individual user funds to their original addresses. We are on the last step and should be able to complete that relatively soon.

Once that is completed, we can begin to work to return your funds to Coinbase.

rggithubether commented 1 year ago

@rggithubether great news! Coinbase has agreed to help returning the WBTC in this transaction: https://etherscan.io/tx/0x1f1c8971dec959d38bcaa5606eb474d028617752240727692cd5ef21a435d847

The DAO has not yet started to reconcile any refunds for CEX sends, so please be patient with us. We are currently in the midst of returning individual user funds to their original addresses. We are on the last step and should be able to complete that relatively soon.

Once that is completed, we can begin to work to return your funds to Coinbase.

Great news! Thank you so much! much appreciated!

rggithubether commented 1 year ago

@joekoh-bg hi just touching base to check if the DAO CEX refund approval is complete? thank you.

rggithubether commented 11 months ago

@joekoh-bg hi any update sir?

joekoh-bg commented 11 months ago

Nothing to update on. DAO still dragging their feet on the air drop step.

rggithubether commented 11 months ago

@joekoh-bg thank u. is there anything we can do to follow up the DAO? my worry is this will drag on and Coinbase gonna forget then we'll start all over again.

rggithubether commented 11 months ago

@tranvictor is there anything you can help with to get the momentum going with the DAO please? thanks in advance. @joekoh-bg

tranvictor commented 11 months ago

Hi everyone, i have inited the tx to distribute just now, waiting for 2 more signers, please take a look here: https://app.safe.global/home?safe=eth:0xA1F7bB557c1fe6Ded1EE6b1775E5B2d2f7598ae4

rggithubether commented 11 months ago

Hi everyone, i have inited the tx to distribute just now, waiting for 2 more signers, please take a look here: https://app.safe.global/home?safe=eth:0xA1F7bB557c1fe6Ded1EE6b1775E5B2d2f7598ae4

@tranvictor thank you for the update. @joekoh-bg

rggithubether commented 11 months ago

@tranvictor @joekoh-bg
how can i check which one is for me in this transaction? i can see that the 36 transactions are complete, but i havent seen my WBTC being refunded yet. kindly advise.

joekoh-bg commented 11 months ago

hi @rggithubether, your refund was not included in this batch. This set specifically did not include the refund to any CEX addresses which is where your's was from. We will handle this refund separately. I am going to bring up your refund to the DAO today, and hopefully can resolve in the coming weeks.

rggithubether commented 11 months ago

@joekoh-bg understood. Thanks for the update.

rggithubether commented 11 months ago

@joekoh-bg hi any updates?