search

Wyn-Price / SecretRooms

8 stars 8 forks source link

1.14.4 - Secret Restone doesn't work #6

Closed UncleSam139 closed 5 years ago

UncleSam139 commented 5 years ago

The Secret Redstone doesn't work if you let it go around a corner or from a higher block to a lower block. Tested it with normal redstone and then it works, but that's not the target of the mod.

Wyn-Price commented 5 years ago

Secret redstone isn't like normal redstone. It can't go up and down hills like normal redstone. It acts as a "tube", only supplying a redstone signal to the blocks directly around it (up, down, north, east, south, west)

fuzzyweapon commented 5 years ago

I think something actually might be broken here even according to what you've said @Wyn-Price ...

In my following examples, I have marked each secret redstone block with a red slash and the torch is an activated (emitting redstone signal) secret torch lever.

The following works as indicated by the redstone receiving the signal...

image

Now the following does not, even though according to what you've said this should be piping out signal to all directions and it is all on the same plane...

image

fuzzyweapon commented 5 years ago

It looks like as soon as you try to change directions using the secret redstone blocks as pipes, they don't carry the signal further.

Yet I can do this:

image

and then this:

image

So, according to the logic of the mod, if it is supposed to be carrying signal between secret redstone blocks in all directions like a pipe, there is a bug. Intuitively, the player would expect this to work if they can pipe secret redstone blocks three in a row on the same plane.

fuzzyweapon commented 5 years ago

What the actual bug looks like is that secret redstone blocks can send redstone signals in all directions, but not receive them.

fuzzyweapon commented 5 years ago

I've seen some strange stuff happening with redstone, and if I get a repro, I will stick in another bug...but I've even seen the signal not carrying but one block off the secret redstone block...or then altogether not picking up the signal from a secret lever even though the lever has been left in the activated state the entire time. I'm only mentioning this briefly here in case it might not be easy to repro this as it might be related.