[support] [ticket 8602] - sui usdc to polygon cannot be redeemed

[ss3388]

Is there an existing issue for this?

• [X] I have searched the existing issues

have you checked our wiki for common solutions?

• [X] I have searched the wiki or docs

Operation Details

- Source Chain: sui
- Source Chain Wallet: 0x01cfece511ac99f26ccdb1b395d9b18300527991f81cd42905ef12ddc7da2575
- Target Chain: polygon
- Target Chain Wallet:0x461a8878060aa45fa685732bff654ca1fdef2830
- Asset Type: token 
- Tx:3Tp3iRzogdk9ekf57kaz8f1BdM2FmqG5t6hj64yv9hid

Current Behavior

User is not able to redeem

error when redeeming: cannot estimate gas; transaction may fail or may require manual gas limit [ See: https://links.ethers.org/v5-errors-UNPREDICTABLE_GAS_LIMIT ] (reason="execution reverted: invalid sender", method="estimateGas", transaction={"from":"0x1C9Ed9D422B357C96B36b66C842037b9B0F0A1b9","to":"0x5a58505a96D1dbf8dF91cB21B54419FC36e93fdE","data":"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","accessList":null}, error={"code":-32603,"message":"Internal JSON-RPC error.","data":{"code":3,"message":"execution reverted: invalid sender","data":"0x08c379a000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000200000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000``

Expected Behavior

• Funds should've arrived into wallet itself

Steps To Reproduce

No response

Anything else?

No response

[dry2022]

ticket 8897 -

tx DzHxQp66NmJdjQB8FFezjBGLcpgVFsAFp4oxTPuvPZKm

SUI -> BSC

same issue

[drisAloma]

(SUI -> Polygon #Ticket-8602) transaction has to redeemed manually, I will post it on slack.

(SUI -> BSC #Ticket-8897) transaction recipient's address is pointing to a contract, I think it might have to be relayed manually as well. There are two other pending transactions like this (SUI -> Polygon):

Ticket #8762 Tx - CKMhisUgDmLTmhBVcJZGEJ9CEtLDobWiE8nq5L4kNni4

Ticket #8915 Tx - Ae2Jh7LhXjRexXUDxhcnqNL99Hhcp314VpeysTJsMqZy

Contract address: 0xCafd2f0A35A4459fA40C0517e17e6fA2939441CA

[sebastianscatularo]

@drisAloma @dry2022 what was the dApp used to perform those txs? Was it portalbridge.com/sui?

[drisAloma]

One of them used SUISWAP, will check in with others

[willis20188]

ticket 8897 -

tx DzHxQp66NmJdjQB8FFezjBGLcpgVFsAFp4oxTPuvPZKm

SUI -> BSC

same issue

Use: https://app.naviprotocol.io/bridge.

[willis20188]

Hello！ any update ?

[sebastianscatularo]

txHash	source	target	emitter	was emitted by token bridge?	Summary	Scanner
3Tp3iRzogdk9ekf57kaz8f1BdM2FmqG5t6hj64yv9hid	Sui	Polygon	21/ccceeb29348f71bdd22ffef43a2a19c1f5b5e17c5cca5411529120182672ade5/10251	no	sui token bridge contract 0xc57508ee0d4595e5a8728974a4a93a787d38f339757230d441e895422c07aba9 differ from ccceeb29348f71bdd22ffef43a2a19c1f5b5e17c5cca5411529120182672ade5	https://wormholescan.io/#/tx/3Tp3iRzogdk9ekf57kaz8f1BdM2FmqG5t6hj64yv9hid
DzHxQp66NmJdjQB8FFezjBGLcpgVFsAFp4oxTPuvPZKm	Sui	Bsc	21/ccceeb29348f71bdd22ffef43a2a19c1f5b5e17c5cca5411529120182672ade5/11200	no	sui token bridge contract 0xc57508ee0d4595e5a8728974a4a93a787d38f339757230d441e895422c07aba9 differ from ccceeb29348f71bdd22ffef43a2a19c1f5b5e17c5cca5411529120182672ade5	https://wormholescan.io/#/tx/DzHxQp66NmJdjQB8FFezjBGLcpgVFsAFp4oxTPuvPZKm
CKMhisUgDmLTmhBVcJZGEJ9CEtLDobWiE8nq5L4kNni4	Sui	Polygon	21/ccceeb29348f71bdd22ffef43a2a19c1f5b5e17c5cca5411529120182672ade5/10623	no	sui token bridge contract 0xc57508ee0d4595e5a8728974a4a93a787d38f339757230d441e895422c07aba9 differ from ccceeb29348f71bdd22ffef43a2a19c1f5b5e17c5cca5411529120182672ade5	https://wormholescan.io/#/tx/CKMhisUgDmLTmhBVcJZGEJ9CEtLDobWiE8nq5L4kNni4
Ae2Jh7LhXjRexXUDxhcnqNL99Hhcp314VpeysTJsMqZy	Sui	Polygon	21/ccceeb29348f71bdd22ffef43a2a19c1f5b5e17c5cca5411529120182672ade5/11152	no	sui token bridge contract 0xc57508ee0d4595e5a8728974a4a93a787d38f339757230d441e895422c07aba9 differ from ccceeb29348f71bdd22ffef43a2a19c1f5b5e17c5cca5411529120182672ade5	https://wormholescan.io/#/tx/Ae2Jh7LhXjRexXUDxhcnqNL99Hhcp314VpeysTJsMqZy

Conclusion

A different contract emitted all the tx, and the user should contact the app owner for assistance, The VAA emitted seems to be incompatible with the token bridge contract, which is why it is failing at the redemption step.

[drisAloma]

Noted @sebastianscatularo Thank you! Just to add, we were able to manually redeem the first transaction on table on our end, though it was the only one pointing to another contract address as recipient. Contract address: 0x461a8878060Aa45Fa685732bfF654Ca1FDeF2830 Which is due to the deprecated npm version.

[dry2022]

Hello! @sebastianscatularo a bunch of user are still having this problem, the MOD from suiswap just opened a ticket saying that user are complaining about this. What can we do for them?

[ss3388]

Just adding this transaction from sui to polygon as well : Ae2Jh7LhXjRexXUDxhcnqNL99Hhcp314VpeysTJsMqZy

[sebastianscatularo]

my first analysis was wrong, only the first transaction is through a legacy contract, the other should be relayed automatically by relayers

txHash	source	target	type	Scanner	Target
tr	Sui	Polygon	transfer with payload	https://wormholescan.io/#/tx/3Tp3iRzogdk9ekf57kaz8f1BdM2FmqG5t6hj64yv9hid	https://github.com/wormhole-foundation/wormhole-connect/pull/662/files#diff-3242bdbdeea1ae665e6580254a696ffd67ffb4a12b21ca1650885a2bf533dc72L48	Legacy
DzHxQp66NmJdjQB8FFezjBGLcpgVFsAFp4oxTPuvPZKm	Sui	Bsc	transfer with payload	https://wormholescan.io/#/tx/DzHxQp66NmJdjQB8FFezjBGLcpgVFsAFp4oxTPuvPZKm	https://github.com/wormhole-foundation/wormhole-connect/pull/662/files#diff-3242bdbdeea1ae665e6580254a696ffd67ffb4a12b21ca1650885a2bf533dc72R58	Non Legacy
CKMhisUgDmLTmhBVcJZGEJ9CEtLDobWiE8nq5L4kNni4	Sui	Polygon	transfer with payload	https://wormholescan.io/#/tx/CKMhisUgDmLTmhBVcJZGEJ9CEtLDobWiE8nq5L4kNni4	https://github.com/wormhole-foundation/wormhole-connect/pull/662/files#diff-3242bdbdeea1ae665e6580254a696ffd67ffb4a12b21ca1650885a2bf533dc72R48	Non Legacy
Ae2Jh7LhXjRexXUDxhcnqNL99Hhcp314VpeysTJsMqZy	Sui	Polygon	transfer with payload	https://wormholescan.io/#/tx/Ae2Jh7LhXjRexXUDxhcnqNL99Hhcp314VpeysTJsMqZy	https://github.com/wormhole-foundation/wormhole-connect/pull/662/files#diff-3242bdbdeea1ae665e6580254a696ffd67ffb4a12b21ca1650885a2bf533dc72R48	Non Legacy

@scnale @solanoepalacio could you check them?

[scnale]

We identified an issue that impacts users who (both must hold to be impacted):

• Use applications built with @wormhole-foundation/wormhole-connect deprecated versions <= 0.0.4.
• Made outbound transfers from Sui to other chains.

We have a plan to fix new and past Sui transfers in these outdated applications but its execution is in progress. I'd like to remind everyone that support for these old versions of wormhole connect is a best effort endeavour and the applications should be updated to enjoy full support and a better user experience.

[drisAloma]

Hello, (ticket-9322) Another transaction has the same issue but this time it was via portalbridge.com/sui @sebastianscatularo .

Source: SUI Target: Polygon Tx: 3ynTKNgxtWmJKLKBgGeSDK7bC3G9de3SXvBvBg8QqTr1

Recipient address: 0xCafd2f0A35A4459fA40C0517e17e6fA2939441CA

However, the transaction shows "Success! The redeem transaction was submitted." on the redeem tab. Could this just be a delay with the relayer?

[drisAloma]

All good with this transaction.

[drisAloma]

Hello, All the previously reported transactions now show "Success! The redeem transaction was submitted." but yet to reflect in the users' addresses.

[scnale]

Hm, I'm not sure why you saw a success message for DzHxQp66NmJdjQB8FFezjBGLcpgVFsAFp4oxTPuvPZKm, CKMhisUgDmLTmhBVcJZGEJ9CEtLDobWiE8nq5L4kNni4 or Ae2Jh7LhXjRexXUDxhcnqNL99Hhcp314VpeysTJsMqZy before. I redeemed those with a special procedure just now. Details:

- Relayed chainId=4, txHash=0x2f16733388899347001a9ee870eab1f16d2f417808996fc35752fa14b31d5c74, 
vaa id: 21/0xccceeb29348f71bdd22ffef43a2a19c1f5b5e17c5cca5411529120182672ade5/11200
original txHash=DzHxQp66NmJdjQB8FFezjBGLcpgVFsAFp4oxTPuvPZKm

- Relayed chainId=5, txHash=0x362bc47f4a7ad09b15afa2d1b4dade7c0e45b08ec713338bf9f7c369f15503d6,
vaa id: 21/0xccceeb29348f71bdd22ffef43a2a19c1f5b5e17c5cca5411529120182672ade5/10623
original txHash=CKMhisUgDmLTmhBVcJZGEJ9CEtLDobWiE8nq5L4kNni4

- Relayed chainId=5, txHash=0x3df80fba233c6169cb5c7990832a162685d7b0d0af54a0dec612c01ea03b5190
vaa id: 21/0xccceeb29348f71bdd22ffef43a2a19c1f5b5e17c5cca5411529120182672ade5/11152
original txHash=Ae2Jh7LhXjRexXUDxhcnqNL99Hhcp314VpeysTJsMqZy

[drisAloma]

Oh, okay, Thank you!