search

XTLS / Xray-core

Xray, Penetrates Everything. Also the best v2ray-core, with XTLS support. Fully compatible configuration.
https://t.me/projectXray
Mozilla Public License 2.0
22.68k stars 3.64k forks source link

[ BUG ] Wireguard Chain speed problem #2850

Open X-Oracle opened 6 months ago

X-Oracle commented 6 months ago

unlike sing-box, speed is very slow when chaing wireguard-outbound (using dialerProxy) to another outboundin xray-core, unlike sing-box (using detour).

AlexeySa commented 5 months ago

I have the same problem. Wireguard over Vmes works very slowly (dialerProxy or proxySettings tag). Xray Wireguard client - 16 Mbit/s Xray Vmes client - 30 Mbit/s Xray Wireguard via Vmes - 50 Kbit/s and lag. Sing-box Wireguard via Vmes (detour) - 25 Mbit/s

OS Windows 10 x64 Xray-core v1.8.6

XRaySup commented 2 months ago

unlike sing-box, speed is very slow when chaing wireguard-outbound (using dialerProxy) to another outboundin xray-core, unlike sing-box (using detour).

how did you chain wireguard to other outbound ? how do you specify the dialerProxy?

chise0713 commented 2 months ago

unlike sing-box, speed is very slow when chaing wireguard-outbound (using dialerProxy) to another outboundin xray-core, unlike sing-box (using detour).

how did you chain wireguard to other outbound ? how do you specify the dialerProxy?

https://xtls.github.io/config/transport.html#sockoptobject

uuonda commented 1 month ago

@chise0713 That would be streamSettings -> sockopt ->dialerProxy. When I open official docs it says

Currently, the Wireguard protocol outbound does not support setting streamSettings

Is this simply outdated?

X-Oracle commented 1 month ago

@chise0713 That would be streamSettings -> sockopt ->dialerProxy. When I open official docs it says

Currently, the Wireguard protocol outbound does not support setting streamSettings

Is this simply outdated?

I don't know. I stopped using it When I saw poor performance.

I just opened this issue to tell devs that sing-box is doing chains with better performance.

The doc statement is probably for when we use kernel wireguard.

uuonda commented 1 month ago

@X-Oracle did you move completely to sing-box or switch just the client?

X-Oracle commented 1 month ago

@X-Oracle did you move completely to sing-box or switch just the client?

I use sing-box for Wireguard but only when chaining it.

I use both of them wherever suited, but I prefer Xray as I'm more experienced in it. I don't like the idea of using Xray server and sing-box client but in this case, I don't have much choice.

CyrusTheV commented 1 month ago

dialerProxy

Dear X-oracle could you please share you sing-box config, I want to know how to use DETOUR to chain proxies