How do we consider a proposal to be valid and can execute?

[0xbeny]

Since there are 3 committees. each of the committees must make a decision on a proposal which means that there are 3 main parameters are involved:

1. Voting Period(Election Period): is how long the proposal is active and accepts votes.
2. Minimum participation(Quorum): is the minimum level of participation required for a vote to be valid.
3. Support threshold(pass rate): is the percentage of votes cast that need to be in favor for the proposal to be accepted.

For further details read this article.

Numbers 2&3 are percentages like 50% and 30%. which means Daofin must calculate 50% of a number. this number varies from committee to committee.

1. Master Node Senate: reads from XDCValidator smart contract of XDPOS

e.g. Total number of MNs = 300, quorum = 50%, threshold = 30% ->  quorum = 150 MNs, threshold ~ 100 MNs

2. People: total supply of XDC token (37,705,012,699 XDC)

e.g. Total Supply = 37,705,012,699 XDC, quorum = 30%, threshold = 50% -> quorum = 11,311,503,809 XDC, threshold 18,852,506,349 XDC

3. Judiciary: length of existing members:

e.g. Total members = 10 Addresses,  quorum = 20%, threshold = 10% ->  quorum = 2 Addresses, threshold = 1 Address

[SupersnipsXDC]

for the people house, if total supply is being chosen as reference then the "quorum = 30%, threshold = 50%" should be lowered significantly while considering actual circulating supply numbers. Another approach would be to fetch circulating supply data and let it be adjusted dynamically (like 20% of circulating supply as Quorum etc...). However, this seems to be technically to difficult to implement currently. I am recommending going with total supply but significantly lowering the percentages.

[SupersnipsXDC]

what happens when the threshold is never met? Lets say the threshold is agreed to be 30% for the people's house but only 20% is voting each time. Is it possible to implement that, if in 2 following voting periods (6 Month period) no threshold has been met that it will automatically lower threshold by 5% etc. ? Also if threshold is met again then threshold requirements automatically are increased again?

[0xbeny]

Agreed on.