search

XinFinOrg / osx-daofin

GNU Affero General Public License v3.0
0 stars 4 forks source link

Types of Proposal #9

Closed 0xbeny closed 9 months ago

0xbeny commented 10 months ago

Along with general purpose proposals which is going to be submitted around the ecosystem growth(grants, core protocol,..), there would be other types of decisions that DAOFIN needs to operate and stay alive:

1- Grant, decision making, etc

2- Voting Settings Proposal: any changes on Quorum and Threshold per each committee.

3- Punishing a spam proposal by the committees : As there is a discussion on #2 , we need a mechanism to punish a bad proposer. so in this case, we need to a proper function on DAO to apply the punishment. This can be form as a proposal.

4- Judiciaries Replacement: As discussed on #1 , same as 2nd option, it should be form as a proposal.

5- Specifying a new Election period

0xbeny commented 10 months ago

Do the criteria of each types of proposals can be different? in other words, Do the quorum and pass rate may varies per proposal type?

SeanXDCAustralia commented 10 months ago

Do the criteria of each types of proposals can be different? in other words, Do the quorum and pass rate may varies per proposal type? I am open to this suggestion. IF I need to formalise my support, just let me know!

0xbeny commented 10 months ago

As discussed, each proposal type has different configurations per committee. this simply means that minimum criteria vary from proposal to proposal.

0xbeny commented 10 months ago

Also, we could enhance the functionalities by applying ProposalType, we(DAO Treasury) can include or exclude one committee in minimum and two committees in maximum.

Example: ProposalType X, only receives votes from Judiciaries and People. not Master Node senate.

This makes DAOFIN more dynamic, there is no code change by devs. the only need is to create a new ProposalType. All changes happen by committees.

Downside: When we delegate this decision to the community. that would be difficult to agree on and takes time. so which means that it's out of control since no single party can decide.

0xbeny commented 9 months ago

Proposal Types Agreed by the community. open a new issue if you want to propose a new proposal type.