kieranjol
commented
5 years ago Hi we can share as much as we can regarding logs, but do you have an email that we could send the XML files to rather than sharing them here?
Closed Leanne93 closed 5 years ago
kieranjol
commented
5 years ago Hi we can share as much as we can regarding logs, but do you have an email that we could send the XML files to rather than sharing them here?
Leanne93
commented
5 years ago This is a copy paste of the results of the script, I just changed some usernames/etc. for privacy's sake.
C:\Users\fakeuser>python -m clairmeta.cli check -type dcp J:\fakedrivename\fakedcpname\DCP
2019-02-25 15:00:33,977 - Clairmeta - ERROR - Could not intialize log file : [Error 3] The system cannot find the path specified: 'C:\\Users\\fakeuser/Library/Logs'
2019-02-25 15:00:34,072 - Clairmeta - INFO - Probing DCP : J:\fakedrivename\fakedcpname\DCP
2019-02-25 15:00:41,641 - Clairmeta - INFO - Total time : 7.57 seconds
2019-02-25 15:00:44,365 - Clairmeta - INFO - Checking DCP : J:\fakedrivename\fakedcpname\DCP
2019-02-25 15:03:00,625 - Clairmeta - INFO - DCP : J:\fakedrivename\fakedcpname\DCP
2019-02-25 15:03:00,628 - Clairmeta - INFO - Size : 11.71 GiB
2019-02-25 15:03:00,631 - Clairmeta - INFO - Warning(s) :
check_dcnc_compliance - ContentTitle must have 12 parts, 11 found
2019-02-25 15:03:00,634 - Clairmeta - INFO - Total check : 53
2019-02-25 15:03:00,634 - Clairmeta - INFO - Total time : 136.26 sec
2019-02-25 15:03:00,637 - Clairmeta - INFO - Validation : Success
C:\Users\fakeuser>
C:\Users\fakeuser>python -m clairmeta.cli probe -type dcp J:\fakedrivename\fakedcpname\DCP
2019-02-25 15:04:47,520 - Clairmeta - ERROR - Could not intialize log file : [Error 3] The system cannot find the path specified: 'C:\\Users\\fakeuser/Library/Logs'
{'asset_list': {u'48339bb9-744e-420c-bad4-26dc60aa74d1': u'fakedcpname_Video.mxf',
u'497eb4ef-dae4-452e-880d-ab784ebda1e3': u'CPL_497eb4ef-dae4-452e-880d-ab784ebda1e3.xml',
u'554a0691-ff9d-41f8-95a7-62a218f12f49': u'PKL_554a0691-ff9d-41f8-95a7-62a218f12f49.xml',
u'b323bee3-4472-42ec-abed-63332eb3800f': u'fakedcpname_Audio.mxf'},
'assetmap_list': [{'FileName': 'ASSETMAP.xml',
'FilePath': 'J:\\fakedrivename\\fakedcpname\\DCP\\ASSETMAP.xml',
'Info': {'AssetMap': {u'AssetList': {u'Asset': [{u'ChunkList': {u'Chunk': {u'Length': 1248,
u'Offset': 0,
u'Path': u'PKL_554a0691-ff9d-41f8-95a7-62a218f12f49.xml',
u'VolumeIndex': 1}},
u'Id': u'554a0691-ff9d-41f8-95a7-62a218f12f49',
u'PackingList': True},
{u'ChunkList': {u'Chunk': {u'Length': 1602,
u'Offset': 0,
u'Path': u'CPL_497eb4ef-dae4-452e-880d-ab784ebda1e3.xml',
u'VolumeIndex': 1}},
u'Id': u'497eb4ef-dae4-452e-880d-ab784ebda1e3'},
{u'ChunkList': {u'Chunk': {u'Length': 12320715338L,
u'Offset': 0,
u'Path': u'fakedcpname_Video.mxf',
u'VolumeIndex': 1}},
u'Id': u'48339bb9-744e-420c-bad4-26dc60aa74d1'},
{u'ChunkList': {u'Chunk': {u'Length': 253206126,
u'Offset': 0,
u'Path': u'fakedcpname_Audio.mxf',
u'VolumeIndex': 1}},
u'Id': u'b323bee3-4472-42ec-abed-63332eb3800f'}]},
u'Creator': u'OpenDCP 0.30.0',
u'Id': u'4aaa82b0-6240-44c1-a63d-803873a756f2',
u'IssueDate': u'2019-02-20T02:55:04+00:00',
u'Issuer': '',
'Schema': 'SMPTE',
u'VolumeCount': 1}}}],
'count_file': 4,
'cpl_list': [{'FileName': 'CPL_497eb4ef-dae4-452e-880d-ab784ebda1e3.xml',
'FilePath': 'J:\\fakedrivename\\fakedcpname\\DCP\\CPL_497eb4ef-dae4-452e-880d-ab784ebda1e3.xml',
'Info': {'CompositionPlaylist': {u'AnnotationText': '',
'AuxData': False,
'ChannelConfiguration': 'Unknown',
'ChannelCount': 2,
'ChannelFormat': 0,
u'ContentKind': u'short',
u'ContentTitleText': u'fakedcpname_SHR-2D-24_F_EN-XX_IE-G_20-EN_2K_20190220_DCP_SMPTE_OV',
u'ContentVersion': {u'Id': u'urn:uri:497eb4ef-dae4-452e-880d-ab784ebda1e3_2019-02-20T02:55:04+00:00',
u'LabelText': u'497eb4ef-dae4-452e-880d-ab784ebda1e3_2019-02-20T02:55:04+00:00'},
u'Creator': u'OpenDCP 0.30.0',
'D-BOX': False,
'DecompositionLevels': 5,
'DolbyVision': False,
'EclairColor': False,
'EditRate': 24,
'Encrypted': False,
'FrameRate': 24,
'HighFrameRate': False,
u'Id': u'497eb4ef-dae4-452e-880d-ab784ebda1e3',
u'IssueDate': u'2019-02-20T02:55:04+00:00',
u'Issuer': '',
'Markers': False,
'PKLId': u'554a0691-ff9d-41f8-95a7-62a218f12f49',
'Picture': True,
'Precincts': 6,
u'RatingList': '',
u'ReelList': [{'AnnotationText': '',
'Assets': {'Picture': {u'AnnotationText': u'fakedcpname_Video.mxf',
'CPLEntryPoint': 0,
'CPLOutPoint': 21064,
u'Duration': 21064,
u'EditRate': 24,
'Encrypted': False,
u'EntryPoint': 0,
u'FrameRate': 24,
'HighFrameRate': False,
u'Id': u'48339bb9-744e-420c-bad4-26dc60aa74d1',
u'IntrinsicDuration': 21064,
'OutPoint': 21064,
'Path': u'fakedcpname_Video.mxf',
'Probe': {u'1': u'128x128',
u'2': u'256x256',
u'3': u'256x256',
u'4': u'256x256',
u'5': u'256x256',
u'6': u'256x256',
u'AspectRatio': 1.85,
u'AssetUUID': u'48339bb9-744e-420c-bad4-26dc60aa74d1',
u'AverageBitRate': 112.3,
u'CodeblockHeight': 3,
u'CodeblockStyle': 0,
u'CodeblockWidth': 3,
u'CompanyName': u'OpenDCP',
u'ContainerDuration': 21064,
u'DecompositionLevels': 5,
u'EditRate': 24,
u'EncryptedEssence': False,
u'LabelSetType': u'SMPTE',
u'MaxBitRate': 125,
u'MultiCompTransform': 1,
u'NumberOfLayers': 1,
u'Precincts': 6,
u'ProductName': u'OpenDCP',
u'ProductUUID': u'43059a1d-0432-4101-b83f-736815acf31d',
u'ProductVersion': u'0.30.0',
u'ProgressionOrder': 4,
'Resolution': '1998x1080',
u'Rsize': 3,
u'SPqcd': u'972096f096f096c08f008f008ee087508750876870057005704777d377d37762',
u'SampleRate': 24,
u'Scod': 1,
u'Sqcd': 66,
u'StoredHeight': 1080,
u'StoredWidth': 1998,
u'Transformation': 0,
u'XOsize': 0,
u'XTOsize': 0,
u'XTsize': 1998,
u'Xsize': 1998,
u'YOsize': 0,
u'YTOsize': 0,
u'YTsize': 1080,
u'Ysize': 1080},
u'ScreenAspectRatio': 1.85,
'Stereoscopic': False,
'TimeCodeDuration': '00:14:37:16',
'TimeCodeIn': '00:00:00:00',
'TimeCodeOut': '00:14:37:16'},
'Sound': {u'AnnotationText': u'fakedcpname_Audio.mxf',
'CPLEntryPoint': 0,
'CPLOutPoint': 21064,
u'Duration': 21064,
u'EditRate': 24,
'Encrypted': False,
u'EntryPoint': 0,
u'Id': u'b323bee3-4472-42ec-abed-63332eb3800f',
u'IntrinsicDuration': 21064,
'OutPoint': 21064,
'Path': u'fakedcpname_Audio.mxf',
'Probe': {u'AssetUUID': u'b323bee3-4472-42ec-abed-63332eb3800f',
'AudioAnalyze': {'pk_lvl_db': u'-1.40|-1.71',
'pk_lvl_db_overall': u'-1.40',
'rms_lvl_db': u'-27.73|-27.68',
'rms_lvl_db_overall': u'-27.71'},
u'AudioSamplingRate': 48000,
u'AvgBps': 288000,
u'BlockAlign': 6,
u'ChannelCount': 2,
u'ChannelFormat': 0,
u'CompanyName': u'OpenDCP',
u'ContainerDuration': 21064,
u'EditRate': 24,
u'EncryptedEssence': False,
u'LabelSetType': u'SMPTE',
u'LinkedTrackID': 2,
u'Locked': 0,
u'ProductName': u'OpenDCP',
u'ProductUUID': u'43059a1d-0432-4101-b83f-736815acf31d',
u'ProductVersion': u'0.30.0',
u'QuantizationBits': 24},
'TimeCodeDuration': '00:14:37:16',
'TimeCodeIn': '00:00:00:00',
'TimeCodeOut': '00:14:37:16'}},
'Id': u'fff722bb-5149-4617-91b7-3a0d62035e08',
'Position': 1}],
'Resolution': '1998x1080',
'Schema': 'SMPTE',
'ScreenAspectRatio': 1.85,
'Sound': True,
'SoundLanguage': 'Unknown',
'Stereoscopic': False,
'Subtitle': False,
'SubtitleLanguage': 'Unknown',
'TotalDuration': 21064,
'TotalTimeCodeDuration': '00:14:37:16'}}}],
'package_type': 'OV',
'path': 'J:\\fakedrivename\\fakedcpname\\DCP',
'pkl_list': [{'FileName': 'PKL_554a0691-ff9d-41f8-95a7-62a218f12f49.xml',
'FilePath': 'J:\\fakedrivename\\fakedcpname\\DCP\\PKL_554a0691-ff9d-41f8-95a7-62a218f12f49.xml',
'Info': {'PackingList': {u'AnnotationText': '',
u'AssetList': {u'Asset': [{u'AnnotationText': u'fakedcpname_Video.mxf',
u'Hash': u'AGipzkzd0b477F6GW7rU3KbnygU=',
u'Id': u'48339bb9-744e-420c-bad4-26dc60aa74d1',
u'OriginalFileName': u'fakedcpname_Video.mxf',
'Path': u'fakedcpname_Video.mxf',
u'Size': 12320715338L,
u'Type': u'application/mxf'},
{u'AnnotationText': u'fakedcpname_Audio.mxf',
u'Hash': u'A2RWKoa4Z3bmhuAG6nGdxM1AxcE=',
u'Id': u'b323bee3-4472-42ec-abed-63332eb3800f',
u'OriginalFileName': u'fakedcpname_Audio.mxf',
'Path': u'fakedcpname_Audio.mxf',
u'Size': 253206126,
u'Type': u'application/mxf'},
{u'Hash': u'QRIJW0OK86YIkPvZKRb2dfk8Smc=',
u'Id': u'497eb4ef-dae4-452e-880d-ab784ebda1e3',
u'OriginalFileName': u'CPL_497eb4ef-dae4-452e-880d-ab784ebda1e3.xml',
'Path': u'CPL_497eb4ef-dae4-452e-880d-ab784ebda1e3.xml',
u'Size': 1602,
u'Type': u'text/xml'}]},
u'Creator': u'OpenDCP 0.30.0',
u'Id': u'554a0691-ff9d-41f8-95a7-62a218f12f49',
u'IssueDate': u'2019-02-20T02:55:04+00:00',
u'Issuer': '',
'Schema': 'SMPTE'}}}],
'schema': 'SMPTE',
'size': '11.71 GiB',
'type': 'DCP',
'volindex_list': [{'FileName': 'VOLINDEX.xml',
'FilePath': 'J:\\fakedrivename\\fakedcpname\\DCP\\VOLINDEX.xml',
'Info': {'VolumeIndex': {u'Index': 1,
'Schema': 'SMPTE'}}}]}
C:\Users\fakeuser>
remia
commented
5 years ago To sumup, I don't think there is any problem with an empty Issuer tag in the PKL / AM (for the CPL the XML tag is optional). I didn't get feedback on any issue related to this but additional experience is always welcome.
I think we could implement a check (as a warning) for empty descriptive fields like this (Issuer, Creator, ..).
kieranjol
commented
5 years ago Cool, my main worry would have been the DCP getting rejected by a very standards compliant server. But perhaps an empty element is more compliant that a completely missing element..
remia
commented
5 years ago Yes, when strictly applying the XML schema from the standard, it's valid because only the tag is required not the content.
It's unlikely that any server would reject a DCP based on this because it's valid per the SMPTE standard. But I can't guarantee this of course (easyDCP treating this only as a warning is another hint).
remia
commented
5 years ago Just added additionnals checks for empty Issuer / Creator / AnnotationText fields in the AssetMap, PKL and CPL. These are warning by default.
See #89
kieranjol
commented
5 years ago Thank you!
Do you have any more details or example of AssetMap / PKL to show (and Clairmeta logs) ?
It should report the absence of Issuer tag when checking the XML file against XSD schema.