Yoast / YoastSEO.js

Analyze content on a page and give SEO feedback as well as render a snippet preview.
GNU General Public License v3.0
403 stars 172 forks source link

Keyphrase density marking mismatch between analysis and highlights #2029

Open dariaknl opened 5 years ago

dariaknl commented 5 years ago

How can we reproduce this behavior?

  1. Use default classic editor.
  2. Go to create post, enter the following text (in Text editor):
    
    <header class="entry__header">
    <h1 class="entry__title">What is cornerstone content?</h1>
    </header>
    <div class="entry__meta">
    <div class="meta meta--full">
    <div class="meta__date">April 11th, 2017</div>
    <div class="meta__author"><a href="https://yoast.com/about-us/team/marieke-van-de-rakt/">Marieke van de Rakt</a></div>

Marieke van de Rakt is both researcher and projectmanager at Yoast. She has a PhD in Social Sciences, her current research focuses on conversion and web analytics. Tags

This post explains everything you need to know about cornerstone content – or evergreen content, as it’s also known. You’ll learn what it is, why it’s important for SEO, how to write this kind of content and how you should link from your posts to your cornerstone articles.

What is cornerstone content?

Cornerstone content is the core of your website. It consists of the best, most important articles on your site; the pages or posts you want to rank highest in the search engines. Cornerstone articles are usually relatively long, informative articles, combining insights from different blog posts and covering everything that’s important about a certain topic. Their focus is to provide the best and most complete information on a particular topic, rather than to sell products. Still, they should reflect your business or communicate your mission perfectly. Cornerstone content can be either a blog post or a page. But whichever they are, you should make sure they’re very well written, update them often, and aim to get them to rank for your most competitive keywords.

Why are cornerstone articles so important for SEO?

Cornerstone content plays a significant role in any SEO strategy. It can be hard to rank for search terms that are very popular, but a cornerstone approach can help you tackle those competitive search terms. If you write a lot of articles on similar subjects, you need to tell Google which of them is the most important. If you don’t, you’ll be eating away your own chances to rank well in the search results. Providing the correct internal link structure between your posts tells Google which article is the most important.

Link structure for cornerstones

Cornerstone articles should have a prominent place on your website. Ideally, someone should be able to click straight from your homepage to your cornerstone articles. Also, all your other posts about similar topics should link back to their corresponding cornerstone article, so its importance is clear from you site structure. As your site develops, you will write tons of new blog posts approaching that topic from other angles, each one linking back to your cornerstone article. This internal linking structure will increase the chance of your cornerstone content articles ranking in Google searches. For example, I write a lot of different posts about SEO copywriting, each looking at a different aspect of SEO copywriting. The cornerstone article for this topic is the Ultimate Guide to SEO Copywriting, and whenever I write a new post on SEO copywriting, I add a link to that cornerstone article. In doing so, I’ll make clear to Google that the Ultimate Guide is the most important article about SEO Copywriting on our site, thereby increasing its chances to rank.

Which articles are my cornerstones?

Choose your cornerstones carefully. Think of the four or five pages you would like someone to read when they first visit your website. These articles should be the cornerstones of your site. Which articles are most important to you? Which are the most complete and authoritative? Do these target the keywords you most want to rank for? The concept of cornerstone content is so important, that our Yoast SEO plugin includes an option to indicate whether or not an article is cornerstone content. If you mark articles as cornerstone, Yoast SEO helps you write a kick-ass article and build a solid internal linking structure. Marking your cornerstone articles means you can create a list of them in your post overview, so you can easily work on improving them. And, most importantly, the link suggestion tool in Yoast SEO Premium will give priority to the articles that you mark as cornerstone content, so you’ll never forget to link to your best article on a certain topic if you write about something related. If your website is enormous, you’ll have more cornerstones than if your website is small. You’ll probably write about more than one topic, so be sure to choose a cornerstone article from each category.

Optimizing your cornerstones with Yoast SEO

Yoast SEO offers some great tools that help you optimize your cornerstone content, including a text link counter, specific cornerstone content analysis and – in Premium – even internal linking suggestions, in which cornerstone articles get priority over other posts.

Read more: How to set up a cornerstone content strategy with Yoast SEO »

Text link counter

With Yoast SEO you can filter your cornerstone articles in the post overview to see how many internal links a post has pointing to it and how many posts it links to. This text link counter is extremely useful because you can see at a glance if your cornerstone content has enough links from other, related posts:  

Cornerstone analysis

If you really want to make your cornerstone articles great, you need specific content analysis for cornerstones. Content marked as cornerstone will be judged more strictly than usual on SEO and readability in the content analysis, as you want this article to be longer, have excellent content, keep the reader’s attention and rank high. Read how this analysis helps you optimize your cornerstones.

Internal linking suggestions

Yoast SEO Premium has an internal linking feature. We analyze what you write and use the most prominent words in your text to determine which articles are related – and therefore which you should link to. Cornerstone articles are treated differently in our calculation of internal linking suggestions because they are more important and have a higher value. To give these articles more prominence, we place the cornerstone articles at the top of the list of the internal linking suggestions. That makes it much easier for you to link to your critical articles.


3. Add Focus keyphrase "cornerstone content".
4. Check feedback:
<img width="602" alt="screenshot 2018-11-27 at 14 25 58" src="https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/19681708/49084653-60caa980-f250-11e8-9e5a-1f020ea8ed69.png">

5. Toggle eye marker, and check your text:

the combination "cornerstone content"is highlighted 11 times.

## Technical info

* Platform: WordPress 
* Platform version: 4.9.8
* Yoast SEO version: 9.3 beta1

If relevant, which editor is affected (or editors): 
- [X] Classic Editor
- [ ] Gutenberg
- [ ] Classic Editor plugin

Beta
- [X] Recalibration beta activated
manuelaugustin commented 5 years ago

Removing the regression label on this, since the actual recognition/marking functionality hasn't changed.

However, there are two issues at hand here: 1) The markers don't mark all keyword occurrences; this is a general marker problem which won't be resolved until we build a tree representation. 2) When there is a match in a sentence, we mark all the occurrences of a word from a keyphrase in a sentence. So when your keyphrases is cats and dogs and you have the sentence This sentence is about cats and dogs and some more cats. We'll mark dogs and both occurrences of cats. This might be confusing for users, who might wonder how we count these occurrences. We might think about ways to improve this (e.g., mark each occurrence only as often as the keyphrase was found).