search

YouTubeHDR / hdr_metadata

159 stars 38 forks source link

P3: Editing the soundtrack of an HDR video with YouTube web interface yields artifacts #5

Closed zmarty closed 7 years ago

zmarty commented 7 years ago

This is a minor bug for me, but I will still list it here so you know about it. I uploaded an HDR video then I replaced its soundtrack using the YouTube remove/replace song feature. This yielded green artifacts all over the HDR video so I had to remove it completely.

YouTubeHDR commented 7 years ago

Could you ping me the link to the video?

zmarty commented 7 years ago

Try this one, since I deleted that video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hefz41EcQcg

Try replacing the music with another song through the Replace Song feature.

YouTubeHDR commented 7 years ago

Could you replace the music from your client and send me the bad video? you may unlist the video and only send me the video id, i.e., the string after "what?v=" in video url.

zmarty commented 7 years ago

Here is the copy with removed audio: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SGWdgC4lnw0

Let's see if it will have the same issue once transcoding is done.

zmarty commented 7 years ago

The copy of the video has finished transcoding and it has the same issue as I reported initially. When I play it on Chrome in Windows the whole screen has green artifacts everywhere. Please check.

YouTubeHDR commented 7 years ago

I see. That is because video edit is not supported for HDR and 360Video for now.

zmarty commented 7 years ago

Then I am not so sure that this item should be closed.