search

Ysurac / openmptcprouter

OpenMPTCProuter is an open source solution to aggregate multiple internet connections using Multipath TCP (MPTCP) on OpenWrt
https://www.openmptcprouter.com/
GNU General Public License v3.0
1.8k stars 258 forks source link

multipath seems to be blocked after new install #3538

Open talitha77 opened 5 days ago

talitha77 commented 5 days ago

Expected Behavior

green flags all round on older OMR and VPS realease

Current Behavior

multipath seems to be blocked message on all three starlinks after new install both on local rpi5 and vps

Specifications

iScreen Shoter - Google Chrome - 240916104430 iScreen Shoter - Google Chrome - 240916104541 using 5.9 with my older vps and all ok.. three starlinks green and happy. I have a new rpi5 with latest OMR and new vps with 6.1.0-22-amd64 # Debian 6.1.94-1 (2024-06-21) x86_64 GNU/Linux and now all three starlinks say that mptcp appears to be blocked. If i swap to the older vps that message goes away on one or two of the wans (of course i get a kernel mismatch).. note that mptctp testing is not there on latest release unless its moved. on the older OMR all starlinks report OK mptcp

Ysurac commented 5 days ago

Aggregation is working or not ?

talitha77 commented 5 days ago

I'm not sure.. speed of starlink fluctuates .. is there a way to test? I'm getting quite a few OpenMPTCProuter daemon.err /usr/bin/ss-redir[18582]: remote recv: Socket not connected

Ysurac commented 5 days ago

Check in Network->MPTCP, bandwitdh tab, and check if more than one WAN is used during a speedtest.

talitha77 commented 5 days ago

iScreen Shoter - Google Chrome - 240916122018

talitha77 commented 5 days ago

iScreen Shoter - Google Chrome - 240916122529 seems so?

talitha77 commented 5 days ago

the problem with being on a ship is that each WAN is subject to outages. So i dont know which to assign as mptcp master. if WAN1 is master and then goes down, i lose connection for several seconds. I have assigned WAN2 as master as its less flaky.

talitha77 commented 5 days ago

iScreen Shoter - 20240916170154282 its all gone horribly wrong

Ysurac commented 5 days ago

Can you test latest v0.61 rc2 ? https://github.com/Ysurac/openmptcprouter/issues/3528

talitha77 commented 5 days ago

v0.61rc2-6.6 r0+27346-c7ba5574f5! (https://github.com/user-attachments/assets/80ed68f5-a039-4c46-94ae-65b62c32af09) nothing works at all now.. no eth1 - eth4, so guess wan1 wan2.. however cannot save and apply changes at all

talitha77 commented 5 days ago

system seems to be unwriteable

talitha77 commented 5 days ago

i will have to put the old one back. i will try to work on the rpi5, perhaps using vlans instead of ethernet adapters.. does omr have the ability to configure vlans?

talitha77 commented 5 days ago

iScreen Shoter - Google Chrome - 240916182243 old one back in and running.. however it chokes when i put the network online.. i assumed a pi4 was too slow - also read only message again.. thats new

Ysurac commented 5 days ago

The filesystem readonly is due to corrupted FS or bad SD card.

talitha77 commented 5 days ago

ah ok.. i guess i will try again with the old image. at the moment it is working so i'll take a rest

talitha77 commented 3 days ago

tried again with different card, shut down properly, new install.. still says filesystem read only

Ysurac commented 3 days ago

What is the filesystem you choose ? ext4 or squashfs ?

talitha77 commented 3 days ago

ext4.. am trying again with 6.0.

talitha77 commented 5 hours ago

I have tried everything i can think of.. now i'm not even getting aggregation. I have a suspicion three starlinks is not a good mix.. initially they all had 192.168.1.x subnets, and things were sort of ok. I changed each starlink routers subnet to 192.168.1.x , 192.168.2,x and 192.168.3.x just to keep them organised but things have got worse.. If its not something particular to starlink then i''m doing something wrong. But i'm just setting up with defaults